Domestic Violence

Judge Sets Further Hearing in Domestic Violence Case Despite Complaining Witness’s Request to Resolve Matter with Formal Apology

San Francisco Superior Court Judge Christopher Hu declined to dismiss a domestic violence case during a June 30 pretrial hearing, opting instead to schedule a subsequent court date despite the complaining witness’s stated willingness to accept an apology from the accused. Deputy District Attorney Samantha Zurcher requested further proceedings, asserting that prosecutorial decisions are typically independent of victim preferences, leading Judge Hu to grant the request while suggesting the defense file a motion to dismiss. The accused, charged with a misdemeanor for property damage, had reportedly paid for the damaged item and was participating in a voluntary domestic violence program.

Santa Clara Court Ruling Exposes Financial Hardship for DV Victims

Santa Clara County Superior Court Judge Kimberly E. Parker denied a victim’s request for peaceful contact with the accused in a domestic violence hearing. The court ruled that the victim must first complete a safety planning class before the matter, which involved considerations of child care arrangements and household finances while a criminal no-contact protective order remained in effect, could be reconsidered.

Judges Blame Fake Shortage as Court Reporters Disappear from California’s Courtrooms

California’s family courts have systematically reduced the presence of official court reporters, leaving millions of legal proceedings without official verbatim records. This development impedes judicial accountability and obstructs meaningful appellate review, occurring as the California Supreme Court evaluates the adequacy of electronic recordings as a substitute for certified shorthand reporters.

Podcast Exposes Justice System’s Criminalization of Abuse Survivors

Journalist and author Justine van der Leun’s new book, “Unreasonable Women: Three Stories of Violence, Imprisonment and Extraordinary Survival,” examines the criminal legal system’s tendency to criminalize rather than protect survivors of domestic violence and sexual abuse. Her investigation highlights instances where individuals, having endured significant abuse, face incarceration for acts committed within the context of their survival.

COURT WATCH: Judge Denies Release, Citing Public Safety Risk and Alleged Pattern of Domestic Violence Violations

The Yolo County Superior Court ordered the continued detention without bail of an accused individual during a pretrial hearing, citing a substantial risk to public safety. The court’s decision reflected the severity of the current felony criminal threats allegations and the accused’s prior history of domestic violence, including probation violations and alleged protective order breaches.

COURT WATCH: Judge Denies OR Release, Sets Bail at $30,000 in Domestic Violence Case

Yolo County Superior Court Judge Danette Brown denied an accused’s request for release on his own recognizance, establishing bail at $30,000. The ruling followed arguments from the prosecution emphasizing the gravity of multiple domestic violence charges and the necessity of victim protection, overriding defense assertions concerning the accused’s financial constraints and transient status.

Both Women Are Dead

Domestic violence homicide is a global issue that is often overlooked, with the same root cause and ownership as “honor killings”, and the same system that keeps women trapped in abusive relationships often fails to protect them.

Everyday Injustice Podcast Ep. 322: Oklahoma Survivors Act and the Fight over Trauma & Justice

The Oklahoma Survivors Act was designed to allow courts to reconsider sentences for people whose crimes were directly connected to abuse they endured, but the law’s implementation has exposed deep resistance within the system, with prosecutors arguing the law could invite exaggerated claims of abuse and open the door for sentence reductions in violent felony cases.

Don’t Wait

Women who are in abusive relationships should prioritize their safety and leave, rather than staying in the relationship out of fear of being judged or alone.