San Francisco Public Defender Mano Raju has been found in contempt of court for refusing to take on additional cases due to excessive workloads, raising constitutional concerns and highlighting the need for increased funding for public defense.
The San Francisco Public Defender’s Office is facing an increased caseload of 55% in felony cases and 78% in misdemeanors, resulting in a staffing shortage and forcing attorneys to work overtime without pay, while the judge’s order to accept all arraignments in felony cases exacerbates the situation.
San Francisco Superior Court Judge Harry Dorfman is presiding over hearings to address the strain on the city’s indigent defense system, as the Public Defender’s Office and the conflict defense panel struggle to ensure timely and qualified legal representation for felony defendants.
Chief Attorney Matt Gonzalez argued in court that the judge has no authority to order the Public Defender’s Office to take on more felony cases, warning such an order would violate attorneys’ limits and clients’ constitutional rights.
The San Francisco Public Defender’s Office testified before Judge Dorfman that their caseloads have increased due to the city’s tougher-on-crime approach, resulting in more complex and time-consuming litigation, and that the office’s declaration of unavailability was necessary to protect the constitutional rights of clients and maintain compliance with the Sixth Amendment’s guarantee of effective assistance of counsel.
San Francisco Chief Assistant District Attorney Ana Gonzalez accused the Public Defender’s Office of mismanagement and falsely claiming an emergency to avoid taking new felony cases, while the Public Defender’s Office argued that the declaration was necessary to protect defendants’ Sixth Amendment rights due to soaring caseloads, staff shortages, and unprecedented discovery burdens.
San Francisco Public Defender Mano Raju has accused District Attorney Brooke Jenkins of flooding the courts with “frivolous and unsubstantiated cases”, leading to an overwhelming caseload for public defenders and a backlog of criminal cases.
By Matt Gonzalez I have been closely associated with the San Francisco Public Defender office for over…
By David M. Greenwald Executive Editor San Francisco, CA – Critics are concerned that newly-appointed San Francisco…
By David M. Greenwald Executive Editor San Francisco, CA – Last week it was reported that appointed…
By David M. Greenwald Executive Editor San Francisco, CA – When prominent San Francisco Chronicle Reporter Heather…
By Darling Gonzalez SAN FRANCISCO, CA – Brooke Jenkins, a former homicide prosecutor, quit Oct. 15 due…
(From Press Release – SF Public Defender’s Office) – Today, on December 4, 2019, the San Francisco…
San Francisco – In 2015, Jose Garcia Zarate made national headlines when he picked up a gun,…
It seems there has been a great rush to judgment on the guilt of Juan Francisco Lopez-Sanchez. …
By Matt Gonzalez The U.S. House of Representatives passed a bill last week called “Kate’s Law” (HR3004)….
Release from San Francisco Public Defender’s Officer A San Francisco Sheriff’s Deputy who was the subject of…