Month: April 2012

Davis City Council Candidates Respond to Sierra Club Yolano Group Questionnaire – Part One

Council-Race-2012

The Sierra Club Yolano Group recently posed a series of local environmental-related questions to the Davis City Council candidates.  Written responses are limited to 400 words for questions relating to the surface water project and 200 words for all other questions.

All responses are reported exactly as received from candidates with the exception that minor formatting changes were made to ensure consistency and to minimize space requirements. Responses were arranged alphabetically by last name for the first question and then rotated for each subsequent question.

 

Vanguard Analysis: Lt. Swartwood Criticized For Abdicating Duties as Incident Commander

Swartwood-batonThe Vanguard fundamentally disagrees with the decision to redact names in the Reynoso Task Force and Kroll Reports.  We believe that responsibility needs to be taken appropriately by those whose decisions or actions contributed to this problem.

In many cases, it does not serve any compelling interest to the name the redacted officers, however, regarding a lieutenant who was the incident commander and who made critical decisions, it is important to identify that Officer P is Lt. Barry Swartwood.

Sunday Commentary: Prosecuting Matzat Isn’t About Sending a Message

Matzat-PosterAbout a week or so ago, I spoke with one of the spokespersons with UC Davis, and they were almost excited that they had found what to them must have looked like the antidote to months of nightmares dealing with the Occupy UC Davis folks.  They don’t need police confrontations, they simply have the DA’s office mail a complaint and suddenly the students are in serious legal jeopardy.

During this conversation, I had an uneasy feeling because, unlike many, I know the DA’s office. I know the court system, and the DA’s office does not mess around. They are not in it to send a message, they are in it to attempt to prosecute to the fullest extent of the law and then some.

Dunning Hammers the Council Over Pay Raise

Council-new.jpgEarlier this week, we once again raised the issue of long council meetings and we were met by defensive skepticism on the part of some on the council.

We fully understand the need to be fair – to not cut off councilmembers and on the other hand, some councilmembers are in fact more succinct than others.  That is why we see this primarily as a scheduling issue, though we think the council should at least look at adopting the policies of the school board to minimize staff presentations that could be read by council in advance.

What Will Picnic Day 2012 Bring?

Picnic-Day-Arrest

Two years ago, Picnic Day resulted in huge problems in the community, as heavy drinking and a large out-of-town population resulted in huge numbers of assaults that threatened the prospect of future Picnic Days.

As a letter from March 28, 2011, indicated, co-signed by Mayor Joe Krovoza and Chancellor Linda Katehi, the city and campus took a number of steps to reduce the problems, including the creation of a Safety Enhancement Zone which increases the fines for violations in downtown areas.  That SEZ has been expanded this year into areas north of Fifth Street in the city’s core.

Matzat Faces 5 Felony, 15 Misdemeanor Vandalism Charges

Matzat-PosterTomas Matzat received good news and bad news on Friday.  The good news is that, in part thanks to the vigilance of his friends and fellow occupiers, he and his attorney met with those in charge of the College of Letters and Science, and it was determined that he would be able to be reinstated as a student so long as he follows some unspecified terms and conditions.

Earlier in the day, Mr. Matzat was scheduled to be arraigned in front of Commissioner Janene Beronio.  However, his attorney requested that the arraignment be delayed until May 11, where he will be arraigned by Judge Timothy Fall in Yolo County Superior County.

Appointment of Carmichael to Chief For One Year Raises Questions

hexter-and-carmichael_lg.jpgAt one level, the hiring of Matthew Carmichael to be the Police Chief of the UC Davis Police Department seemed the obvious choice.  He had already led the department since those fateful days following the November 18 pepper-spray incident, that led to the suspension of his predecessor and nationwide scrutiny on the department.

Supporters can point to his long record of service and training.

Vanguard Council Question #2 – Water Referendum

Council-Race-2012

This is our second installment, in which each of the councilmembers are asked to address a critical issue facing our community in 250 words or less.

Question: On September 6, the City Council passed water rates that some believed to be flawed.  As a result, there was a referendum drive that ultimately obtained enough signatures to put the matter to a vote.  The council then on December 6 rescinded the rate increase and set forth the current process.  The question: Absent the referendum drive, would these changes have occurred and therefore do you believe that as a result of the referendum drive, we will get a better water project and fairer rates, why or why not?

Student Faces Arraignment, Hearing on Student Status on Friday

Matzat-Letters-Science

UC Davis student Tomas Matzat will be arraigned this afternoon on felony vandalism charges, the Vanguard finally confirmed late Thursday.  The arraignment had been something of a mystery, as Mr. Matzat apparently received the date upon his release from custody, but the hearing was not on the public calendar or in the court’s computer system.

Repeated emails to Assistant Chief Deputy DA Michael Cabral were unreturned, despite the request for public information.  The hearing was finally confirmed by the Yolo County Public Defender’s Office.

UC Davis Appoints Carmichael to Succeed Spicuzza, As Interim Police Chief

hexter-and-carmichael_lg

To the surprise of probably no one, Matthew Carmichael was sworn in Thursday to succeed Annette Spicuzza who had retired just one day earlier.  Due to the quick turnaround between the resignation of Ms. Spicuzza and the announcement for the new hire, it was clear that the choice would be Mr. Carmichael, a 27-year veteran of law enforcement, with the last 10 years as a lieutenant at UC Davis. He has served as acting chief since Nov. 21.

Ms. Spicuzza had been on administrative leave while the campus conducted an internal affairs investigation into the Nov. 18 pepper-spraying of demonstrators on the Quad.

First Domino Falls: UCD Police Chief Steps Down

Spicuzza-Pike-Pepper

The first fallout from the pepper-spray report came late yesterday afternoon, when UC Davis police chief Annette Spicuzza, who had been suspended with pay while an internal affairs investigation was conducted, announced her retirement effective Thursday.

“My 27 years in law enforcement have been dedicated to the ethical and committed service to the departments and communities I have been proud to be a part of,” the statement read. “For the past seven years, I have accomplished many good things for both the Police Department and community here at UC Davis; and am grateful to those of you who have remembered this.”

Word To The Wise: Hospice Forum

hospiceBy E. Roberts Musser

The Davis Senior Citizens Commission convened a forum on hospice issues.  There was a selected panel composed of an internest/geriatrician from Vitas Innovative Hospice Care, a social worker from the UC Davis Medical Center, and a representative from Sutter Hospice.  Three Commissioners shared their own hospice experiences, and an attorney-commissioner described two of her clients who had less than optimal hospice encounters.

For the uninitiated, hospice care is of two types:

Commentary: Another Late Night For Council

council-appointment-filled

The council managed to get through a full agenda at their meeting last night.  The unfortunate thing for the public is that it ended around 12:30 midnight.  One of the chief complaints of the citizenry is that meetings go on too late.

This is problematic from our perspective, because it means that the public is unable to participate if they have to get up early for work or if they have young families.  Moreover, it probably impacts the ability of the council to give careful attention and reflection.

 

UCD Student Faces Felony Charges and Possible Expulsion For Vandalism

davis-dozen-rally.jpgThomas Matzat suffered nerve damage when he was one of 10 arrested for misdemeanors during the camp clearing operation back in November 2011.  On Friday, he will be one of 12 arraigned on misdemeanor charges for his bank blocking actions and, reportedly, he will also be arraigned on felony vandalism charges.

Andy Fell, spokesperson for UC Davis, told the Vanguard that “Thomas Matzat, 22, of El Dorado Hills, a UC Davis student, was arrested March 17 on charges of felony vandalism in connection with a series of graffiti incidents on campus.”

City Looks to Tap West Yost to Head Up 95 Million Dollar Wastewater Project

Greenwald-campaign-hsCouncilmember Greenwald Concerned with Using West Yost, Given Track Record

The city staff is recommending the council approve a resolution that would authorize City Manager Steve Pinkerton to execute a consultant agreement with the West Yost/Malcolm Pirnie Team to provide City Representative services for the Secondary and Tertiary Improvements Phase of the Wastewater Improvements Project (CIP No. 8219).

The proposed City Representative consultant agreement is for a not-to-exceed amount of $3,990,000; these funds are budgeted in CIP No. 8219 (Fund 532 – Sewer Capital Replacement Fund). It is the first portion of a forecasted total not-to-exceed fee of $5,390,000 for City Representative fees.

Vanguard Analysis: Report Puts Primary Culpability on Lt. Pike

Pepper-spray

As Kroll aptly notes, Lt. John Pike of the UC Davis Police Department became the face and image of the pepper spray incident.  “The image of Lieutenant John Pike spraying the activists has gone beyond viral to the point of being iconic, with Lieutenant Pike’s image inserted into videos, cartoons, famous paintings, etc,” Kroll writes.

Ultimately, the report by both Kroll and the Reynoso Task Force put the primary culpability on Lt. Pike, at least with regard to the decision to use pepper spray on the protesters in the Quad on November 18, 2011.

Reorganization Plan Continues to Be Source of Controversy in City

city-hallOne of the more controversial changes enacted under the new city manager has been the City Hall reorganization.  Critics charge that these changes have been instituted to sequester the city manager away from the public, and perhaps more importantly, the employees that he manages.

Other have charged that there is an excessive amount of money being spent on the reorganization at a time when the city is looking to cut back on costs.

Some Decry the Paternalistic Rhetoric of the UCD Administration in Justifying the Clearing of the Tents

locoparentisIt was a statement that certainly jumped out of at us as we read the report by the Reynoso Task Force and Kroll.  The statement made by John Meyer seemed like a statement from another time.

He explained, “Our context at the time was seeing what’s happening in the City of Oakland, seeing what’s happening in other municipalities across the country, and not being able to see a scenario where [a UC Davis Occupation] ends well . . . “