WOODLAND, Calif. – During a mental health diversion hearing in Yolo County Superior Court on Monday, Nov. 16, Judge Clara M. Levers denied the accused’s request for treatment-based diversion across multiple criminal cases, despite defense counsel’s arguments that he had only recently begun understanding his mental health conditions and had not yet been given an opportunity to address them through structured treatment.
The accused faced multiple felony and misdemeanor cases involving allegations of burglary, grand theft, receiving stolen property, vandalism, possession of burglary tools, conspiracy, vehicle theft or unauthorized use, possession of a controlled substance for sale, violation of a protective order and disobeying a court order, as well as a probation violation.
The accused sought mental health diversion under California Penal Code Section 1001.36 based on diagnoses of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), amphetamine use disorder and an unspecified mood disorder.
Defense attorney Caryn Warren argued that the accused should have the opportunity to receive treatment through a structured program, emphasizing that he had only recently met with an evaluating doctor and begun learning about his mental health conditions.
According to Warren, the accused had not previously been given an opportunity to address these conditions through treatment and was only beginning to understand how they had affected his life and behavior.
Court records indicated that the accused was already on a waitlist for Walter’s House, a residential substance use disorder treatment facility, while probation officers were also exploring a referral to Cache Creek Lodge.
According to the records, probation had received the Cache Creek referral earlier that morning but had not yet met with the accused to discuss the potential placement.
However, Deputy District Attorney Stefanie DeCillis opposed diversion, arguing that the evidence did not sufficiently establish a connection between the accused’s diagnosed disorders and his alleged criminal conduct.
DeCillis questioned whether the mental health evaluation adequately distinguished between symptoms of PTSD and amphetamine use disorder, noting that the two conditions can share overlapping symptoms.
“It’s not explained how the clinician has, or if the clinician has, distinguished between these two diagnoses, whether these two diagnoses actually do exist together, or if it’s possible that they could be masquerading as one or the other,” she stated.
“Assuming that we get to the place where the court is going to grant this motion, we would need to be assured that the treatment provider has the capability to distinguish those things, to understand if they’re being addressed,” DeCillis explained further.
The prosecution also emphasized the planning and sophistication involved in the alleged offenses, arguing that the accused’s conduct appeared inconsistent with symptoms associated with his diagnoses.
According to DeCillis, evidence from preliminary hearings described repeated and coordinated conduct involving extensive preparation, planning and efforts to avoid detection by law enforcement.
DeCillis further questioned whether the proposed treatment plan was sufficiently individualized, arguing that the evaluating clinician had not clearly identified which symptoms contributed to the accused’s alleged conduct or established whether treatment would address those symptoms.
In response, Warren challenged the prosecution’s reliance on the sophistication of the alleged offenses as evidence against mental health diversion.
“Just because you have a mental disorder doesn’t mean you can’t be as sophisticated in the events you carry out,” Warren argued.
Warren further emphasized that the accused had only recently begun understanding his diagnoses and should be given an opportunity to address them through treatment.
She also argued that the prosecution had not established by clear and convincing evidence that the accused’s mental health disorders were unrelated to his alleged conduct, maintaining that the planning involved in the alleged offenses did not necessarily exclude the possibility that his disorders contributed to his behavior.
In evaluating the motion, Levers acknowledged the accused’s three diagnoses but expressed concern about the lack of information regarding the specific symptoms he experienced.
“The court is operating in a vacuum of information as to specific symptoms,” Levers stated.
The judge referenced evidence from preliminary hearings describing extensive planning and coordination in the alleged offenses, including surveillance, working with accomplices, concealing identity information and taking steps to avoid detection.
Levers also discussed allegations that the accused participated in an operation to sell stolen property through online platforms, which she viewed as evidence that his conduct was financially motivated.
The judge determined that the prosecution had rebutted, by clear and convincing evidence, the presumption that the accused’s diagnosed mental health disorders significantly contributed to the alleged offenses.
Levers further found that the evidence did not sufficiently establish whether the symptoms alleged to have contributed to the accused’s criminal conduct would respond to treatment.
The judge explained that the court lacked specific information about the accused’s symptoms and whether the evaluating clinician was sufficiently familiar with the alleged offenses to determine how those symptoms related to his conduct.
However, Levers acknowledged that the accused had agreed to participate in treatment and that the evidence did not establish the type of unreasonable risk to public safety that would independently disqualify him from diversion.
The judge also indicated that the proposed treatment plan might meet the accused’s mental health needs, although she expressed uncertainty about whether it sufficiently addressed his individual symptoms.
Levers ultimately denied the motion for mental health diversion in the cases before the court.
Although diversion was denied, the court allowed for conditional release to a residential treatment program if an assessment determined that inpatient treatment was appropriate. The records did not establish that the accused had been released or admitted to treatment.
A trial readiness conference was scheduled for Dec. 23, followed by a jury trial on Dec. 28, in one of the accused’s pending felony burglary cases.