Sunday Commentary: Not in Our Town
As Jonathan London, a Davis resident with a periodic Sunday column in the Davis Enterprise, amply notes there is a prevailing sentiment that “this kind of crime does not happen in Davis: This is not who we are.”
As Jonathan London, a Davis resident with a periodic Sunday column in the Davis Enterprise, amply notes there is a prevailing sentiment that “this kind of crime does not happen in Davis: This is not who we are.”
Editor’s Note: This column is re-printed from one published on April 1, 2007.
On August 18 of 2000 state legislation was signed to establish Cesar Chavez Day in California. For many farm workers it was finally an opportunity to honor a man who organized them, led the largest grape industry boycott and formed the United Farm Workers requiring growers to bargain with farm workers who vote for unionization. For many it’s a day to show respect to a man who demanded respect for those, who like him, toiled in the fields day after day.
For me however, it is one out of 365 days, in which I remember a woman, who like Cesar, had motivation sufficient to act. She had “ganas.” A woman who thought of others. A woman who fought for the rights of others in the fields in injustice. A woman who led a strike with her co-workers, marched in on the boss and demanded that cold water, toilet paper and paper towels be provided at all times or they would walk. A woman who got what she wanted because Don Pedro knew that although he could get others to do the work they would not be as dedicated, hard-working, and honest as a woman named Adela Cardona Muñoz Escamilla, lovingly called Doña Adela by my four brothers and three sisters.
In fairness, the question was not framed as well as it could be: “Did the recent hate crime beating change your opinion of Davis?” The problem with it is that you could think that this type of thing always occurs and it would just reinforce your view of Davis, and you could think this is an outlier and therefore discount it as having any meaning.
There has been much speculation about the factors that might lead someone to commit the kind of crime that was perpetrated against Mikey Partida. While some of it may be premature it is a normal human response to try to make sense of something that is so senseless.
Certainly, much more will be learned about the event, the things that led up to it, the story of the perpetrator (whoever it turns out to be), and the likely outcome of a conviction, as the legal process moves forward. We also know with certainty that Mr. Partida will need to go through a painful process of physical and psychological healing. Some scars – physical and psychological – may never fully heal. In quotes from Mr. Partida we have already learned of his fears and anxiety about moving around his hometown. Physical healing is only the first of many long steps he will have to take.
In 1998, there were two horrific hate-motivated crimes. The murder of Matthew Shepard, a student in Wyoming, who was tortured and murdered because of his sexual orientation, and the decapitation of James Byrd, an African-American man, tied to a truck by two white supremacists, dragged and decapitated.
But that was before the New York Times story from early this year, “Can Forgiveness Play a Role in Criminal Justice?” The story told the story of Conor McBride, who was was convicted of shooting his girlfriend of three years when they were both 19.
As I read through some of the obituaries, I realized how much the show, which depicted a wealthy old money industrialist in Manhattan who adopted two poor black children from Harlem, influenced my thinking at a relatively young age.
I attended the “Breaking the Silence of Racism” event at Community Chambers on Saturday – an uncomfortable event in which we told and listened to painful stories with our neighbors in Davis and Yolo County. As I listened to the vignettes (each speaker was limited to about 3 minutes to share their stories), I began to consider not just the content of each but how each struck me in terms of how “real” they sounded to me. In other words, I began to examine how I was hearing the stories.
When I heard the story of a white man my age (a man I know and respect), about how his biracial grandchildren were verbally abused by students in the Davis school system, my throat clenched and my heart raced. As the man nearly broke down, I felt I might do the same. As a grandfather of two (very young) biracial grandchildren I could feel his hurt, anger and confusion and I accepted both the validity of his story and the pain that went with it.
And so yesterday it was D-Day, so to speak, as we had planned and promoted the event, but would anyone come? The answer was a resounding yes. More than 200 people packed into the Community Chambers. The line of people waiting to speak was so long that we quickly and briefly huddled outside and decided to prolong the event so that everyone could speak.
There is little doubt that one of the most controversial topics that I have covered on the Vanguard in its six and a half years of existence is the topic of racism.
This past summer an incident, when a noose was hung from the goalposts of the football stadium at Davis High, triggered a lengthy community debate over what should be done and how much attention we should pay to such an incident.
That’s why we have rules that prohibit campaigning within 100 feet of a polling place. Our assumption is that persuasion has to end at some point, and we do not want voters having to put up with competing campaign claims as they are trying to make the most important decision they have to make for our democracy – at least until the next election.
Lecia Brooks from the Southern Poverty Law Center came to Davis on Monday to speak about the legacy of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr, as well as to talk about contemporary issues of race in our society.
The Southern Poverty Law Center came into being in the early 1970s by two white natives of Montgomery, Alabama, Morris Dees and Joe Levin.
Mayor Joe Krovoza used his comments, opening the 2012 MLK Day Celebration in the City of Davis, to condemn the pepper-spraying incident that occurred last November.
“Intolerance does continue, the reasons for us to gather continue as well,” the mayor said to a capacity crowd at the Varsity Theater on Monday. “War still distracts us from creating social justice, at home it still drains our resources. There are many ways in which we will continue to fight intolerance and [fight for] social justice creation in Davis.”
The path that I am on is not the path that I had chosen. That is fine, I would not change anything for the world.
As I wrote last year, the problem I saw was the loss of the community-based outreach that we once had with the Human Relations Commission, prior to it being disbanded and then reconstituted in the summer of 2006. I spoke at length to the council, highlighting my concerns with what had happened since the disbanding of the Human Relations Commission in 2006, and the disengagement of a number of sectors of Davis’ community from the MLK and other events.
She is a longtime volunteer who works very hard and is totally devoted to many non-profits who do humanitarian work.
Thank you to the Commission for sponsoring this annual event.
It seems in the past there has been, although after discussion with city staff, it does not appear to be a formalized process. This is a lost opportunity to honor people in the community worthy of recognition for such an MLK Day.
The lively group marched on the sidewalk around the park and then gathered at the Rotary Stage for speakers and performers.