In 1922, at Magnus Hirschfeld’s Institute for Sexual Science in Berlin, a woman named Dora Richter underwent the first documented step of a gender-affirming surgical transition. She completed it by 1931. That’s the actual age of the thing people call new, fake, unnatural.
Everything below is younger.
Starting with the easy stuff, since it’s disarming before it’s damning. Sliced bread wasn’t sold commercially until 1928. Bubble gum, that same year. The cheeseburger didn’t exist until 1935. Chocolate chip cookies weren’t a recipe until 1938. Modern frozen food dates to 1924, TV dinners to 1954, the ZIP code on every envelope in America to 1963. Nobody has ever once questioned whether “the greatest thing since sliced bread” deserves to exist because sliced bread happens to be younger than a medical procedure from the same decade.
Age was never actually the standard anyone was using.
Countries get the same pass, and they’re relevant here for the same reason. The modern State of Israel wasn’t founded until 1948, twenty-six years after 1922. Nobody demands a nation prove it’s existed since the dawn of time before agreeing it’s real and gets to keep existing. A country gets treated as a fact of the world the moment it’s declared one. A person’s own body doesn’t get offered that same courtesy, even when the person is considerably older than the country sitting right next to them on this list.
Now here’s the part that actually matters, because “it’s new, so it can’t be trusted” stops being a cute rhetorical trick fast once you look at what else fits that description. The Civil Rights Act didn’t exist until 1964. Interracial marriage wasn’t legal nationwide until 1967, and Alabama kept its own constitutional ban on the books, purely symbolic by then but still there, until the year 2000. When Alabama finally held a vote to remove it, 41 percent of the state chose to keep a ban on interracial marriage in its constitution. In the year 2000.
The Supreme Court upheld forced sterilization in 1927, in Buck v. Bell, and Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes wrote the actual line for the history books himself: “Three generations of imbeciles are enough.” He was writing about Carrie Buck, a young Virginia woman the state had declared feebleminded. She wasn’t. Neither was her mother. Carrie became pregnant at seventeen because she was raped by a relative of her foster family, and the state sterilized her for it anyway, with the Supreme Court’s blessing. More than seventy thousand people, most of them women of color, were forcibly sterilized in this country on the strength of that ruling. It has never been overturned. Nazi defendants at the Nuremberg trials cited it in their own defense.
Between 1932 and 1972, the United States Public Health Service enrolled hundreds of Black men in what became the Tuskegee Syphilis Study, telling them they were being treated for “bad blood,” and deliberately withheld penicillin, a known, working cure, for forty years, specifically so researchers could keep watching what untreated syphilis does to a body. More than a hundred men died from a disease the government could have simply treated. It stayed hidden until a Public Health Service employee named Peter Buxtun, who’d raised objections internally for years and been ignored, finally leaked it to a reporter in 1972.
And marital rape wasn’t criminalized in all fifty states until 1993. A married woman’s legal right to not be raped by her own husband is younger than gender-affirming surgery.
Here’s the part that actually flips the whole premise on its head, and it deserves to be gotten right rather than oversold. Hijra identity in South Asia is roughly four thousand years old, documented in ancient scripture, and once carried real religious and political authority, including formal positions in the Mughal court. Fa’afafine in Samoa, Two-Spirit identities across a wide range of Indigenous nations in North America, and Muxe within Zapotec culture have existed as recognized, respected social roles for centuries, not years. None of this means these are simply older versions of a modern medical category: they’re their own distinct traditions, and pretending otherwise is its own kind of theft.
But the pattern still holds. A strict, two-option, no-exceptions view of gender was never humanity’s ancient, universal default. Over and over, it was European colonizers who arrived, imposed the binary by force, and criminalized what had already existed peacefully for centuries before they showed up.
The people calling gender diversity a modern invention have the history exactly backwards. The binary is the newcomer here, not the rest of us.
Line it all up. Interracial marriage. The end of state-sanctioned sterilization. The end of the government letting Black men die of a curable disease on purpose. A married woman’s legal right to not be raped. Every one of these is younger than the thing currently being dismissed as too new to be real, and not one of them gets treated as suspect for it. Nobody’s out there demanding the Civil Rights Act prove itself because it’s younger than a loaf of bread.
That’s because “new” was never actually the objection.
It just sounds better out loud than the real one.
To comment please go to one of these social media platforms:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DavisVanguard
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoples-vanguard-of-davis-inc/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davisvanguard/
X: https://x.com/davisvanguard
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/vanguardnewsgroup.bsky.social
Subscribe to the Vanguard News letters. To make a tax-deductible donation, please visit davisvanguard.org/donate or give directly through ActBlue. Your support will ensure that the vital work of the Vanguard continues.
