HUD Rule Threatens Housing for Nearly 80,000 People in Mixed-Status Families

WASHINGTON – Nearly 80,000 people, including thousands of U.S. citizen children, could lose federal housing assistance under a new Trump administration rule targeting mixed-status households, even when some family members are legally eligible for the programs.

The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) finalized its new “Verification of Eligible Status” rule Nov. 10, requiring applicants and tenants in covered federal housing programs to provide documentation establishing U.S. citizenship or eligible immigration status.

The rule, published in the Federal Register on Nov. 12, also ends the longstanding practice of allowing mixed-status families to receive prorated housing assistance indefinitely, potentially forcing families to choose between remaining together and retaining their housing.

“It’s unacceptable that America’s homeless veterans, disabled, elderly, and victims of domestic violence languish on waitlists,” HUD Secretary Scott Turner said in a statement announcing the rule.

Turner argued that removing undocumented immigrants and other ineligible individuals from federally assisted housing would reduce the burden on taxpayers and fulfill President Donald Trump’s campaign promises.

In its announcement, HUD described mixed-status households as having “exploited regulatory loopholes” by allowing ineligible noncitizens to reside with family members who qualify for assistance.

However, under the previous rules, undocumented immigrants and other ineligible household members were not themselves entitled to federal housing subsidies. Instead, eligible family members could receive prorated assistance based on the number of people in the household who qualified.

The new rule changes that arrangement by making prorated assistance temporary while household members’ eligibility is verified, rather than allowing it to continue indefinitely.

The changes could affect approximately 20,000 mixed-status households containing nearly 80,000 people, according to an analysis by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP).

The organization estimated that approximately 79,600 people could be affected, including 36,900 children, many of whom are U.S. citizens or otherwise legally eligible for housing assistance.

Rafael Bautista of the San Diego Tenants Union warned that the rule could have far-reaching consequences beyond undocumented immigrants.

Speaking to CBS 8, Bautista said the changes could affect “U.S.-born adults, parents, children, spouses” and other eligible residents.

Bautista warned that families could face the prospect of separating from loved ones or losing the assistance that allows them to remain housed.

“They have to decide whether they’re gonna break up their family or if they are going to be displaced,” Bautista said.

Under the previous regulations, each household member applying for assistance could declare U.S. citizenship or eligible immigration status, or decline to claim eligibility without submitting immigration documentation.

Families containing both eligible and ineligible members could continue receiving reduced assistance based on the number of eligible household members.

The new rule eliminates the option to decline to declare eligible status and requires documentation from all applicants and tenants in covered programs, regardless of age.

That includes U.S. citizens who previously were not required to provide the same level of documentation, as well as elderly residents and children.

The rule takes effect Dec. 14, although HUD has established different compliance deadlines for existing tenants.

Housing providers must notify affected tenants of the new verification requirements within 30 days of the effective date.

Mixed-status households that have not submitted the required documentation generally must do so within 90 days of Dec. 14, with extensions of up to 60 additional days available in certain circumstances.

Other existing tenants generally will be required to provide documentation during their next annual or interim eligibility review.

HUD also provides for temporary deferrals of assistance termination in certain circumstances, potentially lasting up to 18 months. However, those provisions do not preserve the previous system of indefinite prorated assistance for mixed-status families.

According to CBS News, the proposed changes date back to 2019, during Trump’s first administration, but were revived after he returned to office.

In its 2025 analysis, CBPP warned that the proposal could result in thousands of families losing housing assistance, including households with children who are legally entitled to receive benefits.

“Children would be among the hardest hit,” the organization warned.

The organization also raised concerns that the new documentation requirements could jeopardize assistance for otherwise eligible households.

Studies cited by CBPP found that people with low incomes or who have experienced homelessness can have difficulty obtaining required documentation quickly.

Those challenges could leave eligible residents vulnerable to losing assistance if they cannot produce the necessary records within the required timeframe.

“Even if households later submitted documents verifying their eligibility, those who lose their assistance would struggle to regain it,” CBPP warned.

The organization pointed to lengthy waiting lists for federal housing assistance, which it attributed in part to inadequate funding.

The final rule’s own regulatory analysis also acknowledges that replacing mixed-status households with fully eligible households could increase the average amount of federal assistance required per household.

Because mixed-status households previously received prorated subsidies, providing full assistance to replacement households would generally cost more.

Without additional funding, that could mean fewer households receiving federal housing assistance overall, even as the administration argues that the rule will free up resources for eligible families.

CBPP challenged the administration’s argument that the changes would improve housing affordability, warning that the policy could instead increase housing instability.

The organization said Trump had promised “to improve affordability, but this proposal, like many others from this Administration, will have the opposite impact.”

“The people made ineligible by this harsh proposal are important members of our communities, work essential jobs, contribute to our economy, and often have deep roots in our country. But no one should be forced to choose between their housing and their families.”

HUD’s final rule also acknowledges concerns raised by commenters that mixed-status households could be forced to choose between separating family members and losing assistance.

The department maintained that the rule does not require families to separate and pointed to temporary assistance and deferral provisions intended to provide time for households to make alternative arrangements.

However, HUD also stated that housing authorities and property owners are not required to find alternative housing for families that no longer qualify for continued assistance.

Beyond the approximately 20,000 mixed-status households identified in the CBPP analysis, HUD announced that a joint review with the Department of Homeland Security identified nearly 200,000 tenants whose citizenship or immigration eligibility verification was incomplete or unknown.

The department cited those findings as justification for strengthening verification requirements, although incomplete documentation does not necessarily establish that a tenant is ineligible for assistance.

HUD also indicated that the new requirements are part of a broader effort to coordinate with federal immigration authorities, including a data-sharing agreement with the Department of Homeland Security.

The final rule requires housing providers’ verification consent forms to notify tenants that authorities must report household members determined to be present in the United States in violation of federal immigration law.

For mixed-status households, the consequences extend beyond additional paperwork. Families that have relied on prorated assistance to remain housed may now face the loss of that assistance unless they can establish continued eligibility under the new requirements.

To comment please go to one of these social media platforms:

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DavisVanguard

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoples-vanguard-of-davis-inc/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davisvanguard/

X: https://x.com/davisvanguard

Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/vanguardnewsgroup.bsky.social

Subscribe to the Vanguard News letters.  To make a tax-deductible donation, please visit davisvanguard.org/donate or give directly through ActBlue.  Your support will ensure that the vital work of the Vanguard continues.

Categories:

Breaking News Housing Immigration National Issues

Tags:

Author

  • Joseph Passantino

    Joseph Passantino is a sophomore at the University of California, Irvine with a passion for criminal justice reforms and pushing for the rights of everyone to be enforced for all. In his free time, he teaches students in underprivileged communities stem related activities and sings in a local choir.

    View all posts