Month: September 2012

Sunday Commentary: The Best and the Worse Moves by the Davis City Council

welcome-to-wisconsinYesterday’s column on the decision of May 12, 2010, to push forward with a small one-year rate hike, and leave the heavy lifting for future councils, got me wondering what the best and the worst decisions of the council in the last six years (since the Vanguard started on July 30, 2006) were.

That eliminates two of the worst decisions – one that actually led to the formation of the Vanguard in July of 2006 and the other being Covell Village.  Two quick points on the rules for inclusion.  First, these are council decisions, which eliminates worst moments such as the Sue Greenwald-Ruth Asmundson fight or Stephen Souza shouting that they are the deciders.

Commentary: On Media Bias and News Reporting Norms and Impacts

media-logoIt never ceases to amaze me that when the chips are down and all else is failing, the fallback position of any failing campaign – particularly a Republican one – is to blame the messenger, i.e. the media.

Just Google: “Romney unfair media” and you will see a litany of complaints from the right on this subject.  This came up briefly Saturday in a comment.

My View: We Keep Wanting to Bury the Past, But Mistakes Keep Catching Up To Us

Souza-Krovoza-Yost-WaterforumEarlier this week, Councilmember Brett Lee made the comment where he suggested that past councils had done us no favors with regard to financing the surface water project.

“Without casting blame, I must admit I truly lament that the councils that preceded us did not have the foresight to better financially plan for this project,” Councilmember Lee respectfully wrote.  “We have been told that accessing surface water has been in the works ‘for the past 20 years.’ If that has been so, why have we not put any money aside for this very expensive project?”

National View: Why It is Romney and Not Obama on the Ropes This Week

Romney-MJ-VideoIt is difficult to have designed, let alone imagined, a worse week for the Mitt Romney campaign.  How bad was it?  The Romney campaign actually released his tax returns for 2011 to distract from the focus on his statements that came out earlier in the week with regard to 47% of the electorate.

Reading some of the commentary this week from Republicans has been interesting.  Peggy Noonan, former speech writer from the Reagan administration, has been particularly eloquent.

Vanguard Analysis: DA’s Political Masterstroke on Pepper Spray Charges

Pepper-spray

This was the case that Yolo County DA Jeff Reisig and the District Attorney’s Office did not want – it put them into a no-win situation of having to anger a substantial portion of the public no matter how they proceeded.  At first they tried to punt on the issue, but when the California Attorney General’s Office declined to investigate, the matter was dropped right back into their lap.

It was obvious from the start that the police – no matter what the other investigations found – would not be prosecuted criminally in this case.  The question was how to do so in a politically expedient matter.  They got their first break when the internal investigation was significantly divergent from the public Kroll Report.

Critical Tax Measure Too Close To Call

Jerry-BrownA new survey conducted jointly by The Institute of Governmental Studies (IGS) at UC Berkeley and The Field Poll finds the initiative backed by Governor Jerry Brown, Proposition 30, continuing to lead but with support marginally lower than in early July and the undecided proportion increasing.

While much of the focus locally will be on the school parcel tax, Measure E, and the School Board races, one of the most critical election battles outside of Yolo County that will affect us locally is Proposition 30, the Governor’s Tax.

DA Reisig Declines to File Charges Against UCD Police in Pepper Spray Case

Pepper-spray

Ten months and a day after the November 18, 2011, incident that brought world-wide scrutiny, the Yolo County District Attorney’s office did what everyone figured they would do and declined to file charges against Lt. John Pike and other officers who pepper sprayed seated protesters on the UC Davis Quad.

In a letter to UC Davis Police Chief Matt Carmichael, Assistant Chief Deputy DA Michael Cabral wrote, “Civil liability, tactics, and departmental policies and procedures were not considered. We address only whether or not there is sufficient evidence to support the filing of criminal charges in connection with the use of pepper spray by police personnel on November 18, 2011.”

Commentary: Davis Choices on Water Slipping Away

floating-20West Sacramento Option is Not Realistic and Electoral Defeat Self-Defeating –

Davis residents will get to vote on water this March, but what their true options are at that point is not clear.  The good news for Davis residents appears to be that the project has been scaled down to a more reasonable size.  The further good news is that it appears that the city will fix the rate structure that is and has been problematic.

The bad news is that once voters finally step inside of a voting booth next March, their choice will largely have been made for them.

California Moves Forward Allowing Online Voter Registration

debra-bowen-official-photoThere have been past efforts to increase voter participation.  In my first election as an adult, my generation launched “Rock the Vote,” aimed at getting the participation of youth.  Later there was the Motor Voter Law that allowed people to register as they renewed their driver’s license.

Now, Secretary of State Debra Bowen, Senator Leland Yee and San Mateo County Chief Elections Officer Mark Church and the other 57 county elections officials have launched an effort that could be equally revolutionary, as it allows people to register to vote online.

Councilmember Lee Speaks Out on the Water Issue

BrettLeeROver the past year, we have heard a lot about the water project, particularly from the Davis representatives on the JPA – Joe Krovoza and, formerly, Stephen Souza.  But with Mr. Souza’s exit from the council June, Brett Lee has been named to replace him.

In a recent op-ed, he lays out his view on where the city stands on the water issue, ahead of a ballot measure that the city council will soon be finalizing that “will identify the city’s preferred water project and will identify the proposed rate structure and rates that will be put in place to support the added cost of the water project.”

Vanguard Commentary: University, Newspaper, Playing Games With Our Right To Know

Pepper-sprayFor the second time in a month, the Sacramento Bee beat everyone to the punch, publishing what seemed to be internal emails.  This time highlights, among other things, documents the university has attempted to keep under wraps, even from Kroll, about the legal authority under which the university acted.

This is not a small matter, for there are questions about the legal authority under which the university acted.  Questions that now only grow stronger.

Guest Commentary: Writer Asks Council to Rein in City Staff

city-hallBy David Thompson –

Look at what City Staff is doing with our public funds down at City Hall. We ask the newly seated City council to rein in City Staff, stop the waste of public funds and investigate the charges we submitted to the Attorney General?

Yolo County Grand Jury

In June 2011, the City Attorney told the Yolo County Superior Court in person and in a signed declaration (presumably under oath) that the City did not wish to participate in settlement discussions re the Davis Areas Cooperative Housing Association (DACHA). A few weeks later the City Attorney and the City Council sent a report required by law to the Yolo County Grand Jury stating that” settlement discussions had begun.”  Did the City Attorney tell the City Council she had just stated and written the opposite to the Yolo County Superior Court? Did the City Attorney place the Council in the position of having lied to the Grand Jury? The Yolo County Grand Jury should find out?

Special Commentary: A Glimpse into the Truth Beyond the Talking Points

Romney-MJ-Video

Romney’s Video Moment Betrays a Loathing, Disdain for the Average American –

The term class warfare has been increasingly used in recent election cycles to denigrate efforts to point out the disparate impact of policies on the rich versus the poor.  The truth is that there are legitimate policy implications of tax policies that divide the political landscape in this country.

The comments that Mitt Romney is in hot water for making are not new comments, both in the sense that the video is old and in that the thoughts behind them are even older.

Is DBO the Preferred Delivery Method for Water Project?

Sacramento-River-stockLast week at the Water Advisory Committee (WAC) hearings, the committee heard presentations on the Design-Build-Operate (DBO) process which Herb Niederberger, Davis’ General Manager of Utilities, Development and Operations, argued could save the city as much as five to ten million dollars over the course of the contract.

Much of the research backing that appears to be industry-oriented.

Occupy Activists Attempt Another Shutdown of Davis Monsanto Plant Amid Campaign to End GMOs

monsanto-1

Last March, the threat of a protest by the Occupy movement caused the Davis Monsanto Plant to close its doors.  Now, beginning early this morning, protesters, led perhaps by Cindy Sheehan, will be back attempting to shut it down once again.

One of the organizers of the event, Steven Payan of Occupy Woodland, said in a release late Sunday, “This is about hundreds of thousands of lives lost, deformed from chemicals and mass pollution to [the] environment and a company allowed to get away with it because of government ties, and massive lobbying dollars.”

Commentary: Rearguing Target (Sort of) While Moving Forward

DD-BBNThe application to change the zoning for the pad adjacent to Target reignited a debate of sorts about the impact of Target.  The Vanguard is at least attempting to get the city to quantify a notable shift from retail to restaurants and more entertainment-oriented commerce in the downtown over the last six years.

We came up with five pretty recent ones, plus a number of longstanding retail businesses that left for whatever reason.  However, it is not clear just how much of that is based on Target and how much is the economy and shifts in the economy.  After all, the bookstores leaving have as much to do with the shift of how people buy books or no longer buy books.

Sunday Commentary: Evaluating Teachers

schoolIn just over two weeks, the Davis Vanguard will host its first ever official candidate’s forum at Harper Junior High Multipurpose room.  The doors open at 6:30 and the forum begins at 7.

In advance of that we sent out written questions to the candidates, that we will publish early next week.  We say this every year, and perhaps it is the truth, but this is a crucial election for education in Davis – not only do we have five candidates with a broad range of ideas of how to improve our education system, particularly in the wake of consistent and persistent budget crises, but also we have a parcel tax measure on the ballot which means the voters will decide how much in the way of resources the members get to work with.

Commentary: Chief Deputy DA Unimpressed by Crime of Protestors November 18

Raven-JonDA’s Comment Ironic and Telling at the Same Time –

Every so often in a public records request for emails, you get a nugget that is priceless beyond the scope of your immediate inquiry.  The Sacramento Bee reporters who uncovered and reported on UC Davis Campus Counsel communications with the Yolo County DA’s office probably had no idea what they had just uncovered and reported.

The Bee reported yesterday that Senior Campus Counsel Michael Sweeney sought input from Yolo County’s Chief Deputy DA Jonathan Raven.

My View: Multiple Lessons Await Us in Embassy Tragedy

embassy-attackI have always struggled to distinguish in the classical sense the difference between a comedy and tragedy.  I have finally arrived at the reason for the such difficulty – a tragedy should be recast as a comedy of errors.

That, in my view, is largely what has happened this week as we look back upon events.  In many ways, the 2008 election turned not simply on the collapse of the economy, but the poor handling of it by one of the candidates.  John McCain on September 15 said, “fundamentals of our economy are strong.”

Civil Trial for Luis Gutierrez, Shot by Sheriff’s Deputies, To Begin on September 25

img_3299.jpg

By now, most know the story of Luis Gutierrez-Navarro, who on April 30, 2009, was walking home from the DMV on East Gum Avenue in Woodland, when he encountered what turned out to be three plain-clothed officers, Dale Johnson, Herman Oviedo and Hector Bautista in an unmarked Yolo County Sheriff’s Department vehicle.

What happened next is subject to dispute.  However, there seems to have been an attempt to contact Mr. Gutierrez, who had no real criminal record aside from some vehicle code violations. Mr. Gutierrez, for reasons that are unclear, fled the scene, the officers pursued him, and eventually at the top of the overpass there was a final confrontation in which the officers claim he pulled a knife and he was shot and killed.