OAKLAND, Calif. — The Black Panther Apartments has sued San Francisco over a May police raid on the West Oakland affordable housing complex, alleging officers smashed through the building’s entrance, detained and pushed staff members and conducted an unconstitutional search after the robbery suspect they were investigating was already in custody.
The federal civil rights lawsuit, filed Sept. 15 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, accuses San Francisco police of unreasonable search and seizure, excessive force and other civil rights violations stemming from the May 21 operation at the 79-unit complex.
Plaintiffs 7th & Campbell LP, which owns The Black Panther Apartments, Resident Property Manager Misty Cross and security employee Shawn Johnson filed the lawsuit against the City and County of San Francisco and unnamed city employees.
The Black Panther Apartments is a 100% affordable housing development created for low- and extremely low-income residents, including people who have historically faced significant barriers to obtaining housing.
Beginning in July 2024, according to the lawsuit, the development expressly welcomed applications from formerly incarcerated people, except registered sex offenders, along with other economically and socially marginalized individuals and families. More than 7,000 people applied for its 79 residential units.
The complaint states that residents include foreign-born families and a substantial number of Black residents, including single mothers and young children. Many residents came to the complex after experiencing homelessness and living in shelters or vehicles.
The lawsuit alleges that the May 21 police operation followed approximately a month of SFPD surveillance of the building.
According to the complaint, officers told building personnel that SFPD had been watching the property for about 30 days. The lawsuit further alleges an officer acknowledged that police had accessed the building’s internet servers and the private server associated with Apartment 515 without the owners’ knowledge or consent or a warrant.
Those allegations have not been adjudicated, and the plaintiffs state that they do not yet possess all records concerning the surveillance, warrant application, police communications or planning of the operation.
The May 21 operation was connected to an alleged San Francisco robbery. Minutes before SFPD entered the apartment complex, officers arrested an 18-year-old robbery suspect approximately one block from the building, according to the complaint.
The plaintiffs allege approximately 20 plainclothes SFPD officers subsequently approached the building in unmarked vehicles, put on police vests and demanded entry.
Johnson was outside the entrance when officers ordered him to open the door, according to the lawsuit. Johnson asked officers to wait while he contacted Cross, who was on-site, and requested that they show him a warrant.
Rather than present the warrant, the complaint alleges, an officer knocked Johnson’s cellphone from his hand while he was speaking with Cross, pushed him against a wall and handcuffed him.
Johnson was accused of obstruction, but the criminal charge was subsequently dismissed, according to the complaint.
Elaine Brown, former Black Panther Party leader and CEO of Oakland & the World Enterprises, a co-owner of the property, described the encounter in a June statement.
“Arriving in unmarked cars and in street clothes, a gang of about 20 San Francisco police amassed at our front door and demanded our security open it. When asked what their business was and to show a search or arrest warrant, they refused, raising a sledgehammer and battering ram and smashing through our front door,” Brown said.
The lawsuit alleges officers gathered outside the entrance with breaching equipment and warned building personnel, “Open up or we’ll break down the door!”
Officers then allegedly shattered the glass entrance and partially tore the door from its hinges before approximately eight officers entered the lobby.
The complaint maintains that the forced entry occurred despite repeated requests from building personnel that officers identify their legal authority and despite being told Cross was in the building and coming downstairs to meet them.
Cross arrived in the lobby as approximately eight officers entered an elevator, according to the lawsuit. She repeatedly asked them to show her the judicial warrant authorizing their entry and search.
The complaint alleges officers refused and physically pushed Cross away from the elevator when she attempted to keep its doors open while requesting the warrant.
Cross nevertheless entered the elevator because she was concerned officers were proceeding toward a resident’s apartment without management knowing the legal basis for the search or being able to ensure the resident’s safety, according to the lawsuit.
Police proceeded to Apartment 515, where officers conducted a search purportedly for evidence connected to the San Francisco robbery.
The complaint alleges the robbery suspect was already in police custody and officers knew he was not inside the apartment.
Officers searched the residence and ultimately emerged carrying a paper bag containing a pair of shoes and a jacket, according to the lawsuit.
The plaintiffs allege officers did not provide Cross with documentation until after completing the search. The complaint further alleges the document appeared to have been completed by hand in the fifth-floor hallway after officers had already entered and searched the apartment.
The plaintiffs acknowledge, however, that they do not currently possess the complete warrant affidavit, application, supporting declarations, surveillance materials and other records used to obtain the warrant.
Those materials are within the possession of SFPD and San Francisco and will be the subject of discovery, according to the complaint. The plaintiffs allege, subject to that discovery, that the search exceeded the lawful scope of any warrant that had been issued or was otherwise executed unreasonably in violation of the Fourth Amendment.
Attorney Adanté Pointer, who represents The Black Panther Apartments, questioned both the scale and manner of the police operation.
“This is a prime example of how police continue to corrode the community’s trust,” Pointer said. “It’s clear to me that law enforcement wanted to send a message to the entire community.”
Pointer also questioned why police used force to enter the building after the robbery suspect had already been taken into custody.
“They ransacked this guy’s apartment, tore it up and left. What did they ‘find?’ A pair of shoes and a jacket? They’d already arrested the suspect,” Pointer said. “If you’ve got the guy in custody, and you were looking for clothing, why did you have to break down a door, talk crazy and act like you were going after a murderer still on the loose?”
The complaint also raises questions about the Oakland Police Department’s involvement in the operation.
According to the filing, SFPD notified Oakland police before the operation that officers intended to conduct an investigation in the 1600 block of Seventh Street.
The complaint states OPD subsequently acknowledged that SFPD requested assistance with “crowd-control” and that Oakland police “honored” that request. The San Francisco and Oakland police unions later characterized the incident as a “coordinated operation,” according to the complaint.
The lawsuit states that the precise extent of OPD’s involvement, including communications between the departments and the actions of Oakland officers, remains subject to discovery.
The plaintiffs also allege Brown and Cross attempted to file a criminal complaint with Oakland police following the incident but were initially directed away from making an in-person complaint.
According to the lawsuit, statements were eventually taken from Brown and Cross, but the plaintiffs allege no meaningful follow-up occurred.
The complaint argues that the effects of the May 21 operation extended beyond physical damage to the building.
It alleges residents and employees were left fearful for their safety in their own homes and suffered continuing distress from the manner in which law enforcement entered and occupied the building.
The plaintiffs allege the operation involved the destruction of the building’s entrance, detention of personnel, physical displacement of the property manager, surveillance of internet servers, entry into and search of a resident’s apartment, seizure of property and intimidation of residents.
The lawsuit states that a baby and teenage girl lived in the apartment that officers searched.
The plaintiffs contend, subject to discovery, that the May 21 operation resulted from coordinated governmental decision-making and that the search, detention and use of force were unreasonable, excessive and lacked constitutionally sufficient justification.
The complaint names the City and County of San Francisco and Does 1 through 50 as defendants. The unnamed defendants are alleged to be city employees whose identities the plaintiffs intend to determine through discovery.
The lawsuit asserts nine causes of action, including unreasonable search and seizure and excessive force under the Fourth Amendment, negligence, trespass, vandalism, violations of California’s Bane Act, battery, unlawful arrest and violations of the Ralph Act.
The plaintiffs seek damages for alleged constitutional and civil rights violations, destruction of property, emotional distress and other injuries, along with attorneys’ fees and other relief. They also seek punitive damages against the individual defendants.
The litigation follows an earlier tort claim against San Francisco arising from the same incident. The owners and management had also called on Alameda County District Attorney Ursula Jones Dickson to pursue criminal charges against the officers.
At the time, Pointer said the claim gave San Francisco an opportunity “to address the harm these officers caused when they abused this community and caused innocent people to suffer from their tactics.”
“Should San Francisco refuse to make the community whole, then we will file a civil lawsuit,” Pointer said.
That lawsuit has now been filed.
Pointer previously summarized the allegations against the officers: “These officers committed an unreasonable and unlawful search, wrongfully destroyed property, used excessive force to enter the building, unlawfully detained an employee, and violated the Fourth Amendment rights of all residents.”
To comment please go to one of these social media platforms:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DavisVanguard
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoples-vanguard-of-davis-inc/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davisvanguard/
X: https://x.com/davisvanguard
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/vanguardnewsgroup.bsky.social
Subscribe to the Vanguard News letters. To make a tax-deductible donation, please visit davisvanguard.org/donate or give directly through ActBlue. Your support will ensure that the vital work of the Vanguard continues.