28 California District Attorneys Join Lawsuit to Block Newsom’s Death Row Commutations as Legal Battle Intensifies

Gov Newsom toured San Quentin on Friday with Warden Chance Andes

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — A coalition of 28 California district attorneys, law enforcement organizations and relatives of murder victims has filed a legal challenge seeking to block Gov. Gavin Newsom’s proposed commutation of all 548 death sentences in the state, escalating a confrontation over executive clemency, victims’ rights and the future of capital punishment in California.

The petition, filed with the California Supreme Court and dated Nov. 15, argues that Newsom exceeded his constitutional authority by proposing to replace every death sentence with life imprisonment without the possibility of parole without conducting individualized reviews or providing advance notice to prosecutors and victims’ families.

The filing comes as Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer has separately submitted an amicus curiae brief challenging the governor’s proposed commutations involving 382 incarcerated people whose prior felony convictions require additional review by the California Supreme Court.

The legal challenges follow Newsom’s Nov. 5 announcement that he intends to commute every existing death sentence before leaving office, citing racial disparities, wrongful convictions, geographic inconsistencies and systemic failures that he argues make California’s capital punishment system fundamentally unreliable.

The coalition includes Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman, Sacramento County District Attorney Thien Ho, Riverside County District Attorney Michael Hestrin, San Diego County District Attorney Summer Stephan and Kern County District Attorney Cynthia Zimmer.

Other participating prosecutors represent Amador, Butte, Calaveras, El Dorado, Fresno, Kings, Lake, Madera, Merced, Modoc, Monterey, Placer, San Bernardino, San Luis Obispo, San Mateo, Shasta, Solano, Stanislaus, Sutter, Tehama, Tulare, Ventura and Yuba counties.

Although some media accounts have reported approximately 30 district attorneys participating, the petition itself identifies 28 individual county prosecutors.

The lawsuit was organized by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, headed by former Sacramento County District Attorney Anne Marie Schubert, with the California District Attorneys Association, the Peace Officers Research Association of California and several victims’ advocacy organizations also participating.

“This lawsuit is about protecting the constitutional rights of victims, defending the rule of law, and ensuring that no Governor is above the law,” Schubert said in a statement announcing the litigation.

“The Governor’s clemency power does not authorize mass commutations that disregard constitutional safeguards, legally required procedures, or victims’ rights,” she continued. “By predetermining the outcome for every inmate on death row, the Governor has abandoned his responsibility to exercise meaningful discretion.”

The petition seeks an immediate stay preventing Newsom and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation from implementing the proposed commutations while the court considers the legal challenge.

It also asks the justices to declare invalid any commutations issued without compliance with the statutory procedures that the petitioners contend govern executive clemency.

Prosecutors Challenge Newsom’s Authority

The central legal dispute concerns Article V, Section 8 of the California Constitution, which authorizes the governor to grant reprieves, pardons and commutations but requires approval from at least four Supreme Court justices before clemency can be granted to someone twice convicted of a felony.

Newsom identified 382 individuals whose commutations require that recommendation, leaving 166 others whose cases do not require the same constitutional review.

The petitioners contend that the governor’s authority is also constrained by Penal Code Section 4805, which provides for notice to district attorneys and an opportunity for victims to be heard when commutation applications are considered.

They argue that Newsom cannot avoid those requirements merely because he initiated the clemency process himself rather than responding to applications from incarcerated individuals.

Greg Totten, chief executive officer of the California District Attorneys Association, said the governor’s approach deprived prosecutors of the opportunity to provide information about individual cases.

“The Governor’s failure to provide legally required notice to prosecutors has deprived them of the opportunity to provide critical information and ensure that victims and their families are heard,” Totten said.

The petition also alleges that the governor’s classification of individuals requiring Supreme Court review contains errors, citing criminal history discrepancies identified by the Kern County District Attorney’s Office.

Among the examples are questions about whether certain prior convictions should qualify individuals for mandatory Supreme Court review and whether summary criminal history records adequately reflect the underlying court proceedings.

Those allegations have not been adjudicated by the court.

The petitioners argue that the potential discrepancies demonstrate why prosecutors should have been consulted before the governor announced his proposed commutations.

The legal challenge also invokes California voters’ decisions to retain capital punishment, including the defeat of repeal initiatives in 2012 and 2016 and approval of Proposition 66 in 2016.

But those elections did not eliminate the governor’s separate constitutional clemency authority, which remains available even when the underlying punishment is authorized by law.

The question before the courts is not whether California retains the death penalty, but whether Newsom can exercise his existing clemency authority categorically and what procedural restrictions apply.

Spitzer Files Separate Supreme Court Challenge

Spitzer, who has emerged alongside Hochman as one of the most vocal prosecutorial defenders of capital punishment, filed his separate amicus brief Monday, Nov. 16.

His office argues that Newsom abused his constitutional authority by seeking to commute the death sentences of 382 individuals with prior felony convictions without evaluating the circumstances of each case.

“There is nothing more sacred than democracy and the rule of law,” Spitzer said in his announcement.

“Our criminal justice system does not bend with the political winds, and one man – even if he is the governor – does not get to put his thumb on the scales of justice simply because he does not like the law,” he added.

Spitzer also announced plans to seek separate writ relief concerning the commutations that do not require Supreme Court approval.

At a Nov. 12 news conference, Spitzer appeared with relatives of murder victims, including Steve Herr, whose son Samuel was murdered by Daniel Wozniak.

As the Vanguard previously reported, Spitzer accused the governor of disregarding jury verdicts, the suffering of victims’ families and the repeated decisions of California voters to retain capital punishment.

Hochman, meanwhile, has aligned himself with the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation’s challenge and is among the 28 district attorneys named in the petition.

“We stand firmly with the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation in challenging this arbitrary commutation that sidelines victims’ families and disregards the will of California voters, juries and judges,” Hochman said in a Nov. 12 statement.

Hochman has argued that executive clemency should involve individualized consideration of each person’s criminal history, conduct and circumstances.

He has also maintained that his office will continue considering the death penalty in qualifying murder cases regardless of Newsom’s action.

The proposed commutations would not repeal capital punishment or prevent district attorneys from seeking death sentences in future cases.

Nor would they authorize the release of anyone currently sentenced to death. The affected individuals would instead serve life sentences without the possibility of parole.

Newsom and Legal Scholars Defend Broad Clemency

Newsom and supporters of his proposal reject the argument that categorical clemency necessarily constitutes an abuse of executive authority.

In his Nov. 5 open letter to Californians, Newsom described his decision as the culmination of decades of opposition to capital punishment and his assessment that California cannot administer the death penalty fairly.

“I take this action because I firmly believe that state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California’s values, undermines the foundations of our legal system, and diminishes each of us,” Newsom wrote.

His administration has argued that the statutory procedures cited by prosecutors govern applications for clemency rather than preventing a governor from initiating commutations under his own constitutional authority.

That interpretation is disputed by the petitioners and remains unresolved.

The governor’s position has received support from constitutional scholars, including UC Berkeley Law Dean Erwin Chemerinsky, UC Berkeley professor Jonathan Simon, Harvard Law professor Carol Steiker, Stanford Law professor Robert Weisberg and Cornell Law professor Sandra Babcock.

In a Nov. 5 letter to the California Supreme Court, 19 scholars of law, history, philosophy and government argued that broad grants of executive clemency are firmly rooted in American constitutional practice.

They pointed to historical examples of categorical pardons and commutations, including Illinois Gov. George Ryan’s decision to commute 167 death sentences in 2003 after concluding that the state’s capital punishment system could not reliably distinguish between those who should live and those who should die.

Other governors have used clemency to eliminate existing death sentences in states including Oregon, Maryland and Colorado.

The scholars maintain that the governor’s constitutional authority does not disappear simply because the rationale for clemency applies to an entire category of incarcerated people rather than a single individual.

Jonathan Simon, a professor at UC Berkeley School of Law who has studied capital punishment and the exercise of executive clemency, told the Vanguard in an earlier interview that the Supreme Court’s constitutional role is not to substitute its own policy preferences for those of the governor.

Simon explained that the review process is designed to guard against abuses of executive power, including favoritism and corruption.

He argued that a categorical commutation affecting every person sentenced to death presents a different situation from a governor granting special treatment to a politically connected individual.

Under that interpretation, the relevant legal inquiry is whether the governor’s exercise of clemency constitutes an abuse of discretion, rather than whether the justices agree with his assessment of capital punishment.

The scholars’ historical arguments also challenge the characterization of Newsom’s proposal as an unprecedented use of clemency.

Although the number of affected individuals makes the proposed action unusually large, categorical death sentence commutations have been undertaken by other governors.

California’s situation is distinctive because the state maintains one of the nation’s largest death row populations despite having conducted no executions since 2006.

Newsom imposed a formal moratorium on executions in 2019, but the death sentences themselves have remained in effect.

Victims’ Families Are Divided

The coalition’s lawsuit places considerable emphasis on victims’ rights, arguing that the proposed commutations disregard the experiences of families who have spent decades pursuing justice through the criminal courts.

Topo Padilla, president of Crime Victims United, said families were particularly upset that they learned about the governor’s plans through public announcements rather than individualized notification.

“Victims are not an afterthought in our justice system,” Padilla said. “They have constitutional rights, and those rights must be respected.”

Brian Marvel, president of the Peace Officers Research Association of California, emphasized that some of the condemned individuals were convicted of murdering law enforcement officers.

“Dozens of the inmates on Governor Newsom’s blanket commutation list are individuals who murdered peace officers in the line of duty,” Marvel said.

But survivors of violent crime do not share a uniform position on capital punishment, and some have publicly supported Newsom’s decision.

Tinisch Hollins, a leader with Crime Survivors for Safety and Justice who lost two brothers to violence, told the Vanguard in an earlier interview that she supports the commutations.

“We have seen cases be overturned. We’ve seen innocent people condemned,” Hollins said. “We know that folks who are sentenced, especially Black people and people of color, are disproportionately receiving harsh and extreme sentences.”

Hollins argued that victims’ families often receive inadequate assistance from the criminal justice system, regardless of whether prosecutors pursue the death penalty.

“What is consistent across the board for all survivors, regardless of their perspective on the death penalty, is that survivors don’t get the support that they deserve,” she said.

She pointed to the need for greater access to trauma recovery services, victims’ compensation, information about criminal proceedings and resources that help families rebuild their lives.

Hollins also questioned the morality of government executions.

“And just morally, I don’t want my tax dollars to be used to put people to death as punishment,” she said.

Another survivor, Paul Wilson, whose wife, Christy Lynn Wilson, was killed in the 2011 Seal Beach mass shooting, has publicly challenged Spitzer’s position.

Wilson previously supported capital punishment and campaigned for Spitzer but subsequently changed his views after years of court proceedings.

Speaking to City News Service, Wilson acknowledged that he and Steve Herr, who appeared alongside Spitzer, had experienced comparable losses but reached different conclusions.

“I walk in the same shoes as Mr. Herr,” Wilson said. “We just have a different view.”

Wilson said he found finality in the life-without-parole sentence imposed on Scott Dekraai, who killed his wife and seven other people.

The differing perspectives illustrate a significant limitation in arguments that portray either support for or opposition to capital punishment as representing the collective wishes of murder victims’ families.

A Broader Debate Over Racial Disparities and Wrongful Convictions

Beyond the procedural dispute, Newsom’s proposed commutations have revived questions about the fairness and reliability of California’s death penalty system.

The governor has cited racial disparities, the risk of executing innocent people, geographic variations in capital sentencing and the extraordinary expense of maintaining a system that has not carried out an execution in more than two decades.

Death penalty opponents argue that these problems are structural rather than isolated and cannot be resolved through individualized appellate review alone.

The California Appellate Project, Habeas Corpus Resource Center and Office of the State Public Defender have argued that systemic defects provide a legitimate basis for broad executive clemency.

Their position is that a governor need not conclude that every condemned person is innocent or that every individual death sentence was improperly imposed to determine that the punishment itself should no longer be carried out.

The proposed commutations would leave the underlying murder convictions intact and retain the most severe custodial sentence available under California law: life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.

Prosecutors opposing the plan have raised concerns that subsequent changes to sentencing laws or future grants of clemency could eventually allow some individuals to seek release.

However, such possibilities are separate from the immediate legal consequences of Newsom’s proposal, which would not itself confer parole eligibility.

The dispute therefore reflects two competing conceptions of executive clemency.

Prosecutors and victims’ rights organizations challenging Newsom argue that individualized review and procedural participation are essential safeguards against arbitrary executive action.

The governor and supporters of the commutations maintain that clemency also serves as an independent constitutional check on punishment when an elected executive concludes that the legal system has produced outcomes that should no longer be enforced.

Supreme Court Faces Multiple Challenges

The California Supreme Court had already begun reviewing the governor’s proposal before the coalition filed its petition.

On Nov. 9, Chief Justice Patricia Guerrero invited interested parties to submit legal arguments addressing Newsom’s request for approval of the commutations requiring judicial review.

The court established a Nov. 24 deadline for applications and proposed amicus briefs and a Dec. 4 deadline for the governor’s consolidated response.

Spitzer’s filing addresses that review process, while the coalition’s petition seeks additional relief, including an immediate stay and an order preventing implementation of the commutations.

The petitioners also ask the court to require the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to continue treating the affected individuals as sentenced to death until the legal questions are resolved.

The Supreme Court has not yet ruled on the merits of the coalition’s claims or determined whether the governor’s proposed commutations can proceed.

The pending proceedings will require the justices to consider both the scope of Newsom’s constitutional clemency authority and the statutory procedures prosecutors argue he must follow.

The 548 individuals affected by the governor’s announcement remain incarcerated, and the proposed commutations would replace their death sentences with life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.


To comment please go to one of these social media platforms:

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DavisVanguard

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoples-vanguard-of-davis-inc/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davisvanguard/

X: https://x.com/davisvanguard

Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/vanguardnewsgroup.bsky.social

Subscribe to the Vanguard News letters.  To make a tax-deductible donation, please visit davisvanguard.org/donate or give directly through ActBlue.  Your support will ensure that the vital work of the Vanguard continues.

Categories:

Breaking News Everyday Injustice

Tags:

Author

  • David M. Greenwald

    Greenwald is the founder, editor, and executive director of the Davis Vanguard. He founded the Vanguard in 2006. David Greenwald moved to Davis in 1996 to attend Graduate School at UC Davis in Political Science. He lives in South Davis with his wife Cecilia Escamilla Greenwald and three children.

    View all posts