Woman released without charges after federal agents detained her outside Stanislaus County jail, raising questions about use of force and immigration enforcement on county property
MODESTO, Calif. — A 23-year-old pregnant U.S. citizen was pepper-sprayed, forced facedown onto the pavement and detained by federal immigration agents outside the Stanislaus County jail Sunday, Nov. 15, before being released hours later without charges, according to news reports and statements from her attorney.
Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, a resident of Ceres, was recording an Immigration and Customs Enforcement operation when agents confronted her in a parking lot outside the jail. Video circulating online shows agents physically restraining Andrade, deploying pepper spray and forcing her to the ground as her husband warned that she was pregnant.
The incident has raised questions about the use of force by federal immigration agents against U.S. citizens, the constitutional protections afforded to people documenting immigration enforcement and the growing practice of conducting federal immigration arrests outside California county jails.
According to reporting by the San Francisco Chronicle, federal agents were attempting to arrest an individual who had recently been released from the county jail when several community members began recording the operation.
Andrade was among those observing the agents. Video of the encounter reportedly shows her following an agent around a parked vehicle before an agent grabbed her arm and another deployed pepper spray.
Agents subsequently forced Andrade to the pavement and handcuffed her while she was facedown.
Her husband, Adolfo Talavera, repeatedly warned the agents that she was pregnant, according to accounts of the incident.
Andrade, who was reportedly approximately 12 weeks pregnant, said she struck her abdomen hard when agents took her to the ground.
The encounter was documented in video circulated by community members, including footage attributed to the Stop ICE Network and the social media account Brown Issues.
Andrade disputed an allegation that she assaulted a federal agent, saying that any physical contact was incidental and that an agent subsequently accused her of striking him.
Her attorney, Patrick Kolasinski, challenged the circumstances of her detention and questioned the federal agents’ conduct.
Andrade was transported to an ICE office in Stockton, where she remained in federal custody for several hours, according to the Chronicle.
She said she was not formally processed at the Stockton facility and that her sister ultimately summoned an ambulance to obtain medical assistance.
Andrade, who has diabetes, was subsequently transported to a hospital for evaluation. She said two federal agents remained with her during the medical examination and that she was denied access to an attorney.
She later reported that medical personnel found no apparent harm to her or her pregnancy.
Andrade was released Sunday night without criminal or immigration charges.
The absence of charges does not, by itself, establish that her detention was unlawful, but the circumstances raise significant questions about the justification for the arrest and the level of force used by federal agents.
Under the First Amendment, individuals generally have the right to observe, record and criticize law enforcement officers performing their duties in public places, provided they do not unlawfully interfere with those activities.
The Fourth Amendment separately protects individuals against unreasonable searches and seizures, including detentions and arrests unsupported by the requisite legal justification.
Claims of excessive force during an arrest are generally evaluated under an objective reasonableness standard that considers the circumstances confronting officers, including whether the individual posed an immediate threat and whether the person was actively resisting.
The video and Andrade’s account raise questions about whether she presented a threat sufficient to justify the use of pepper spray and a physical takedown, particularly given her pregnancy.
However, a complete assessment would require examination of the full encounter, including any events preceding the recorded confrontation and the agents’ explanation for their actions.
The Stanislaus County Sheriff’s Office acknowledged the incident but said its deputies were not involved in Andrade’s detention.
Sheriff’s Office spokesperson Erich Layton told the Chronicle that the encounter occurred in the department’s parking lot and referred questions about the federal operation to ICE.
The statement leaves unanswered whether county authorities had advance knowledge of the operation, whether federal agents were monitoring jail releases independently and whether any information about individuals leaving the jail had been provided to immigration authorities.
Those questions are particularly significant in California, where state law generally restricts the use of local law enforcement resources for federal civil immigration enforcement.
The California Values Act, commonly known as SB 54, limits cooperation between state and local law enforcement agencies and federal immigration authorities, subject to statutory exceptions.
The law does not prohibit federal agents from independently conducting immigration enforcement, but it restricts certain forms of assistance that local authorities may provide.
There has been no public evidence establishing that Stanislaus County deputies improperly assisted ICE during Sunday’s operation.
Nevertheless, the incident comes amid growing scrutiny of federal immigration enforcement around county jails throughout California.
In Alameda County, officials have challenged ICE operations outside Santa Rita Jail, raising questions about the use of county property for federal immigration enforcement.
Monterey County has similarly objected to federal immigration activities on county property, including locations associated with its jail and other public facilities.
Those disputes reflect increasing tension between federal immigration enforcement practices and California jurisdictions seeking to maintain separation between local government operations and civil immigration enforcement.
The Modesto encounter also highlights the potential consequences for community members who attempt to document federal enforcement operations.
Civil rights advocates have repeatedly warned that aggressive enforcement tactics against observers and protesters can discourage individuals from exercising constitutional rights, even when they are not themselves targets of immigration enforcement.
In Andrade’s case, the fact that she is a U.S. citizen underscores that the consequences of immigration enforcement operations can extend beyond people subject to removal proceedings.
The incident also raises questions about federal policies governing the use of force against pregnant individuals and the provision of medical assistance to people injured during enforcement operations.
The Department of Homeland Security and ICE have not provided a substantive public explanation of the detention in the reporting reviewed.
It remains unclear whether agents prepared a use-of-force report, whether the allegation that Andrade assaulted an officer was formally documented or whether federal authorities have initiated an internal review.
Kolasinski has indicated that federal immigration arrests outside the Stanislaus County jail are not isolated incidents, suggesting that Sunday’s confrontation occurred in the context of an established enforcement practice.
The extent of any coordination between federal agents and county officials remains unknown.
Andrade’s release without charges leaves several central questions unresolved: why agents detained her, what justified the use of pepper spray and physical force, whether agents knew she was pregnant before taking her to the ground, and whether federal authorities will investigate the encounter.
The Stanislaus County Sheriff’s Office has maintained that its deputies did not participate in the detention, while ICE has yet to publicly explain the actions of its agents.
To comment please go to one of these social media platforms:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DavisVanguard
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoples-vanguard-of-davis-inc/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davisvanguard/
X: https://x.com/davisvanguard
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/vanguardnewsgroup.bsky.social
Subscribe to the Vanguard News letters. To make a tax-deductible donation, please visit davisvanguard.org/donate or give directly through ActBlue. Your support will ensure that the vital work of the Vanguard continues.