Law professor and civil rights attorney Joseph Margulies argues that American society has become so focused on condemning people accused of horrific crimes that it has lost the capacity to understand the circumstances behind their actions, a failure he believes is central to the case of Lindsay Clancy, who faces murder charges in the deaths of her three children.
Margulies contends that the public’s tendency to judge people solely by their alleged actions, rather than examining the circumstances that led to them, reflects a broader culture that has become increasingly resistant to empathy and forgiveness.
In a Nov. 17 commentary published by Verdict, Margulies challenges readers to consider whether understanding Clancy’s mental health and personal circumstances should influence how society and the criminal justice system judge her.
Clancy faces three counts of first-degree murder in connection with the deaths of her three children in January 2023.
Following the deaths, Clancy reportedly cut her neck and wrists and jumped from a second-story window. She survived but was left paralyzed from the waist down.
Her defense has argued that she lacked criminal responsibility because she was experiencing postpartum psychosis at the time of the children’s deaths.
The defense relies on the legal standard established in the 1967 Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court decision Commonwealth v. McHoul.
Under that standard, “A person is not criminally responsible if, as a result of mental disease or defect, that person lacked substantial capacity either to appreciate the wrongfulness of the conduct or to conform the conduct to the requirements of law.”
After seven days of trial, the judge declared a mistrial Sept. 4, 2026, when the proceedings could not reach a resolution. A new trial is scheduled for March 29, 2027.
Margulies argues that the public has largely failed to consider why Clancy allegedly committed the acts for which she is charged.
He begins by contrasting two questions: “What did Lindsay Clancy do?” and “What happened? What brought an otherwise joyful and loving mother to kill her children and try to kill herself?”
Margulies argues that these questions reflect fundamentally different approaches to understanding criminal behavior and that prosecutors must consider which framework will guide their presentation of the case.
He explains that his personal and moral philosophy can be summarized in the phrase, “There is no them, there is only us.”
For Margulies, focusing exclusively on what someone has done creates a separation between the accused and the rest of society. Asking what happened, by contrast, encourages an examination of the circumstances that contributed to the person’s actions.
Margulies contends that American society has become increasingly resistant to that kind of understanding, arguing that people frequently “mock frailty and deride empathy.”
He describes the resulting culture as “uncaring, ungenerous and unkind,” suggesting that this attitude makes it more difficult to recognize the humanity of people accused of serious crimes.
Margulies argues that Clancy should be judged in the context of her entire life rather than solely through the acts she is accused of committing.
“We must judge the whole of who she is, and not merely the darkness that overtook her,” he writes.
He emphasizes that examining the circumstances surrounding Clancy’s alleged actions does not necessarily mean excusing them. Rather, he argues, understanding those circumstances is essential to reaching a fair judgment.
Margulies suggests that society sometimes resists learning more about people accused of terrible crimes because of “fearing that it will soften our heart and incline us to judge Ms. Clancy in something other than an insensate fury.”
He further argues that the tendency to portray people accused of serious crimes as fundamentally different from everyone else prevents meaningful examination of their experiences.
“In all the ways that matter, Lindsay Clancy is no different from you or me,” Margulies writes.
According to Margulies, describing someone like Clancy as a “Monster” creates a moral separation that discourages people from considering the circumstances behind the alleged crime.
He contrasts a society that asks only, “What did you do?” with one willing to ask, “What happened? What brought you to this place?”
Margulies concludes that the justice system and the public should consider Clancy’s humanity alongside the gravity of the allegations against her.
“Lindsay Clancy is any of us, and we must judge her in that spirit,” he writes.
He closes by asking readers to consider how their judgment might change if Clancy were someone they knew personally.
“If she were your sister and you knew what happened to her, would you condemn her to spend the remainder of her life in prison?”
To comment please go to one of these social media platforms:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DavisVanguard
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoples-vanguard-of-davis-inc/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davisvanguard/
X: https://x.com/davisvanguard
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/vanguardnewsgroup.bsky.social
Subscribe to the Vanguard News letters. To make a tax-deductible donation, please visit davisvanguard.org/donate or give directly through ActBlue. Your support will ensure that the vital work of the Vanguard continues.