Editor’s note: For the past several months, the Vanguard has been investigating longstanding water quality concerns at Mule Creek State Prison and their potential impact on incarcerated people and the surrounding Ione community. This is the second installment in a planned series of at least 10 articles examining documented wastewater violations, reported health problems, drinking water safety and questions of government accountability.
IONE, Calif. – An incarcerated man at Mule Creek State Prison alleges he has faced years of delay and inadequate treatment for numerous serious medical conditions, including spinal degeneration, heart problems and chronic pain, while also struggling to obtain copies of his medical and mental health records.
Randy Skains, who has been incarcerated at Mule Creek State Prison since October 2013, said his health has continued to deteriorate while in custody. Skains, who is 71, described living with numerous medical conditions and taking approximately 41 pills per day, including seven for his heart.
Skains said he suffered a heart attack in 2015 and was more recently diagnosed with atrial fibrillation, commonly known as AFib. He also reported experiencing lung and liver problems, thyroid issues, essential tremor, degenerative joint and disc disease, gastrointestinal conditions and numbness in both feet.
One of his most significant concerns is the treatment of his spinal condition. Skains said he was first diagnosed with spinal problems in 2003 and was later told the degeneration in his neck was too severe for surgery.
According to Skains, a physician, Dr. Atul Verma, told him nothing could be done surgically because his neck had deteriorated too severely. Skains said a neurosurgeon reached a similar conclusion after reviewing his condition and an abnormal bone density test.
Skains disputes that assessment, however, and said records in his possession contradicted what he had been told about the severity and treatment of the condition.
“I got the reports,” Skains wrote to The Vanguard, alleging that he talked to Dr. Verma with the documents.
According to Skains, he was then scheduled to see the neurosurgeon again. He ultimately underwent neck fusion surgery on March 13, 2026, and said his neurosurgeon is now working to arrange additional surgery involving his lumbar and thoracic spine.
Skains also alleged delays in treatment intended to prepare him for surgery. He said testing showed low levels of vitamin D, vitamin B and calcium. Although vitamins were ordered immediately, Skains claims calcium was not ordered for another 86 days.
He said he questioned Dr. Verma about the delay and alleges the physician responded, “You inmates in here get better treatment than I do.”
The Vanguard has not independently confirmed the statement or contacted Dr. Verma for this account.
Skains also described ongoing dental problems. Beginning Sept. 8, 2025, he said 10 of his teeth were extracted over approximately three months. Nearly a year later, he said he still had not received replacement teeth despite repeatedly being told the issue would be addressed.
Skains said he was most recently told another step in the process had to be redone and that he would have to wait an additional six to eight weeks.
His complaints go beyond individual treatments. Since November 2023, Skains said he has repeatedly attempted to obtain complete copies of his medical and mental health records.
He alleges that the records he has received have been incomplete and unorganized, including pages containing records from different years printed on opposite sides of the same sheet.
Skains said he filed an appeal concerning the records but believes officials responded to his complaints about employee conduct rather than addressing whether he had received his complete medical file. He said subsequent requests for records have gone unanswered.
California Correctional Health Care Services (CCHCS) states that incarcerated patients may request copies of their protected health information through an institution’s Health Records Department. According to CCHCS, Release of Information staff are responsible for printing requested documents and providing them to the incarcerated patient.
Skains said that there are still gaps in the records he has received, alleging that some physician progress notes are missing for periods ranging from several months to as long as six years.
“If it’s not in the record, it doesn’t exist,” Skains recalled being told by a physician.
He maintains that the records he has obtained support at least some of his allegations and said approximately a dozen staff members would be willing to provide information about his treatment. He also identified mental health professionals, including psychiatrists, psychologists and social workers, who he said know about his care.
Skains has now pursued the prison health care grievance process over what he describes as a deliberate indifference to his medical needs. He said his latest appeal was sent to officials in Elk Grove in August.
Under California’s prison health care grievance system, incarcerated people may submit a CDCR 602 HC grievance regarding their medical care and, if dissatisfied with the institutional response, appeal the matter to the headquarters level. Those appeals are sent to the Health Care Correspondence and Appeals Branch in Elk Grove.
CCHCS provides medical care within California’s state prisons, while CDCR’s Division of Health Care Services provides mental health and dental services.
The most recent publicly listed Office of the Inspector General medical inspection identified in its publications database rated the overall quality of health care at Mule Creek as “adequate” for the period inspected in 2021.
For Skains, however, the issue is not just whether he has received medical treatment, but how long he says he has had to fight to receive it.
“I have been getting sicker every day,” Skains wrote, alleging that medical staff often respond to health problems with medication rather than addressing their underlying causes.
Skains said he hopes his ongoing grievance will result not only in better care for himself, but improvements for other incarcerated people experiencing similar problems.
“I hope to live long enough to get a suit filed,” he wrote, adding that he hopes “all of us will get medical treatment, not just a pill.”
To comment please go to one of these social media platforms:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DavisVanguard
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoples-vanguard-of-davis-inc/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davisvanguard/
X: https://x.com/davisvanguard
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/vanguardnewsgroup.bsky.social
Subscribe to the Vanguard News letters. To make a tax-deductible donation, please visit davisvanguard.org/donate or give directly through ActBlue. Your support will ensure that the vital work of the Vanguard continues.