After State Supreme Court Strikes Down Mandatory Life Without Parole for Felony Murder, More Than 1,000 Await Justice

HARRISBURG, Pa. — A groundbreaking March 2026 ruling by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court declared mandatory life without parole for felony murder unconstitutional under the state Constitution. Yet more than 1,000 incarcerated individuals, including Jerome Coffey, who has spent more than three decades behind bars, remain in legal uncertainty, without automatic resentencing and facing procedural barriers to relief.

A Nov. 17 investigation by Victoria Law for Bolts examines the widening gap between constitutional recognition and practical justice as lawmakers, courts and advocates grapple with whether to apply the ruling retroactively.

The decision, Commonwealth v. Lee (No. 3 WAP 2024), issued March 26, struck down mandatory life without parole for felony murder but left unresolved whether individuals whose convictions had already become final would be entitled to resentencing.

The court stayed its decision for 120 days to allow the Pennsylvania General Assembly to consider legislative remedies. However, that period expired without lawmakers reaching an agreement.

Coffey, who has spent 33 years incarcerated, is among those challenging their sentences under the new ruling. In September, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court agreed to consider whether its decision should apply retroactively to his case.

The Abolitionist Law Center, which represents Coffey, argues that unresolved questions surrounding his original conviction further underscore the importance of providing relief to those already serving mandatory life sentences.

Coffey was convicted of second-degree murder in 1994 in connection with a fatal shooting that occurred two years earlier. Prosecutors alleged that he participated in the abduction of the victim before another individual fatally shot him.

According to Bolts, Coffey’s attorneys have raised concerns about unreliable witness testimony and potentially exculpatory evidence that was not disclosed to his trial attorney.

Coffey received a mandatory sentence of life without parole, while his co-defendant was acquitted.

In a Sept. 29 statement, the Abolitionist Law Center said Coffey has spent decades challenging a conviction involving no physical evidence linking him to the crime, a recanted witness statement, allegedly suppressed evidence and claims of ineffective assistance of counsel.

“Mr. Coffey is one of more than 1,100 people who are waiting for the promise of the Supreme Court’s decision in Lee to be fulfilled,” said Bret Grote, legal director of the Abolitionist Law Center.

Coffey’s appeal highlights broader systemic concerns surrounding the felony-murder rule, which permits individuals to be convicted of murder even when they did not personally kill or intend to kill another person.

Pennsylvania law classifies felony murder as second-degree murder and allows prosecutors to pursue murder convictions against individuals who participate in certain underlying felonies that result in a death.

Before the Supreme Court’s ruling, individuals convicted of second-degree murder automatically received life sentences without the possibility of parole, regardless of their individual culpability.

The case that prompted the ruling involved Derek Lee, who was convicted of second-degree murder for his participation in a 2014 robbery in Pittsburgh during which his accomplice fatally shot the victim.

Lee challenged his mandatory sentence under both the Eighth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and Article I, Section 13 of the Pennsylvania Constitution.

Although the court determined that the sentencing scheme did not violate the Eighth Amendment under existing federal precedent, it concluded that Pennsylvania’s constitutional prohibition against cruel punishments affords greater protections.

Chief Justice Debra Todd, writing for the majority, stated, “Ultimately, we find that the mandatory sentencing scheme for second degree murder poses too great a risk of disproportionate punishment, and, thus, find it to be cruel.”

The court vacated Lee’s sentence and remanded his case for resentencing. It did not overturn his murder conviction or categorically prohibit life without parole for felony murder.

As Bolts reported in its April 1 coverage of the ruling, Pennsylvania and Louisiana were the only two states requiring life without parole for felony-murder convictions.

California offers a potential blueprint for addressing some of the issues surrounding felony-murder convictions, although its reforms differ from the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s ruling.

In 2018, California passed Senate Bill 1437, which narrowed felony-murder liability and established a petition-based mechanism for resentencing, now codified under Penal Code Section 1172.6.

Under the revised law, felony-murder liability generally applies to individuals who personally committed a killing, aided and abetted a killing with the intent to kill, or were major participants in the underlying felony and acted with reckless indifference to human life.

California’s legislation established a procedure through which eligible individuals convicted under previous standards could petition the courts for relief.

Pennsylvania, by contrast, has yet to establish a comprehensive mechanism for addressing sentences imposed before its Supreme Court’s decision.

The distinction is significant because applying Pennsylvania’s ruling retroactively would not necessarily result in immediate release. Instead, affected individuals could receive new sentences or opportunities to establish their eligibility for parole.

Legislative efforts to address the Pennsylvania ruling have revealed disagreements over the length of time individuals should serve before becoming eligible for parole.

The Republican-controlled Pennsylvania Senate passed Senate Bill 1400 in June, proposing parole eligibility after 35 years for individuals already serving life sentences for second-degree murder.

The legislation also proposed sentencing restrictions for future convictions while preserving the possibility of life without parole under certain aggravating circumstances.

The Democratic-controlled House pursued a different approach through House Bill 1042, proposing parole eligibility after 30 years for individuals already serving life sentences.

Although both chambers supported some form of retroactive relief, lawmakers failed to reconcile their competing proposals.

The November election could alter the prospects for legislative action. Democrats gained control of the state Senate while retaining the House and governorship, according to Bolts.

Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro previously submitted an amicus brief supporting Lee’s constitutional challenge and publicly welcomed the Supreme Court’s March ruling.

Meanwhile, Coffey’s attorneys are pursuing relief through the courts rather than waiting for lawmakers to resolve their differences.

The Abolitionist Law Center said the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s decision to consider Coffey’s appeal could determine whether more than 1,100 individuals serving mandatory life sentences for felony murder are entitled to resentencing proceedings.

To comment please go to one of these social media platforms:

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DavisVanguard

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoples-vanguard-of-davis-inc/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davisvanguard/

X: https://x.com/davisvanguard

Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/vanguardnewsgroup.bsky.social

Subscribe to the Vanguard News letters.  To make a tax-deductible donation, please visit davisvanguard.org/donate or give directly through ActBlue.  Your support will ensure that the vital work of the Vanguard continues.

Categories:

Breaking News Everyday Injustice

Tags:

Author

  • Natzumy Zavala

    Natzumy Zavala is an undergraduate student pursuing a B.A. in Social Ecology with a double major in Psychological Science at the University of California, Irvine. Their acadmic and professional focus centers on justice,equity and systemic reform, particularly for marginalized communities. Natzumy aims to intergrate evidence-based investigation pratcices into their future career as a criminal investigator for the FBI, with a commitment to transparency, accountbability and amplifiying unrepresented vioces. Their works seeks to challenge injustices and drive meaingful change in the judicial system and beyond.

    View all posts