Crime Victim Advocates Move to Block Newsom’s Death Row Commutations, Legal Experts Say Efforts Are ‘Frivolous’

Gov Newsom toured San Quentin on Friday with Warden Chance Andes

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — On Nov. 5, California Gov. Gavin Newsom announced that he would commute the death sentences of all 548 people on California’s death row, reducing their sentences to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole, according to an article by the Los Angeles Times.

Newsom, a longtime critic of the death penalty who dismantled San Quentin State Prison’s execution facilities and issued a moratorium on executions after taking office in 2019, called the death penalty a “failure” and argued that capital punishment fails to deter crime and wastes state resources.

Since Newsom’s announcement, more than half of California’s county district attorneys have thrown their support behind the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, a Sacramento-based advocacy organization that supports crime victims’ rights. The foundation has filed a petition for a writ of mandate with the California Supreme Court seeking to halt the governor’s commutations, according to a Nov. 19 article by the Los Angeles Times.

The foundation and other opponents of Newsom’s commutations argue that the governor failed to meet certain procedural requirements before announcing his decision.

In the petition, the petitioners argued that “[Newsom] claimed that the statute enacted to guarantee victims of crime notice and an opportunity to be heard before a commutation decision was made does not apply merely because he was acting unilaterally.”

The statute referenced in the petition is a provision of the California Penal Code requiring that the district attorney of the county where a conviction occurred be notified of an application for clemency, according to the governor’s explanatory statement.

Newsom argues that this statute does not apply when the governor acts unilaterally. In most cases involving commutations, a person convicted of a crime applies to the governor for a reduction in their sentence. However, Newsom’s Nov. 5 announcement was made on his own initiative, without applications from the 548 individuals.

In the same explanatory statement, the governor established that he would seek the California Supreme Court’s approval for commutations involving 382 individuals who had been twice convicted of felonies.

Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of the University of California, Berkeley, School of Law, said during a news conference that “Frankly, I think the arguments are frivolous…If we just focus on the law, it’s clear that Newsom has the authority to commute these sentences in this way,” according to the Times’ Nov. 19 article.

Fellow UC Berkeley law professor Elisabeth Semel, a longtime leader of the university’s Death Penalty Clinic, said, “Either the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation and the district attorneys do not understand what the governor did on Nov. 5…or do not understand the law.”

Legal experts defending Newsom’s announcement argue that the California Constitution provides for limited judicial review of clemency decisions involving individuals who have been twice convicted of felonies.

In 2018, the California Supreme Court issued an administrative order clarifying its role in reviewing clemency requests.

“[T]he California Constitution does not require the justices of this court to determine whether, in the view of each justice, the applicant deserves clemency,” the justices said in the order.

Proponents of the death penalty have criticized the governor’s claims that those receiving commutations will spend the remainder of their lives in prison, citing changes in sentencing laws that allow some incarcerated people sentenced to life without parole to seek reductions in their sentences.

“Contrary to the Governor’s assertion, life without the possibility of parole no longer guarantees that you will spend your life in prison,” said Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman, who joined the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation’s legal challenge.

“The Governor cannot tell victims’ families with any degree of certainty that these murderers will spend the rest of their natural lives behind bars.”

However, Hochman’s claim, reported in the Times’ Nov. 19 article, was criticized by legal scholars such as Michael Romano, director of the Three Strikes Project at Stanford Law School.

“[T]hese regulations have nothing to do with the people who’ve been sentenced to death,” Romano said. “The people who receive clemency from Gov. Newsom received the longest possible sentence available in American law and that is where they will stay.”

Critics of the commutations argue that Newsom is attempting to circumvent the Legislature and courts to effectively end the death penalty in California. While no person has been executed in the state since 2006, voters in both 2012 and 2016 rejected ballot measures seeking to abolish capital punishment.

According to the Times, experts say the California Supreme Court could decide the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation’s petition as early as Nov. 23, but may wait until as late as Christmas to announce its decisions on clemency for individuals with two felony convictions.

Under the California Constitution, Newsom would need the recommendation of at least four California Supreme Court justices to commute the sentences of those 382 individuals.

To comment please go to one of these social media platforms:

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DavisVanguard

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoples-vanguard-of-davis-inc/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davisvanguard/

X: https://x.com/davisvanguard

Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/vanguardnewsgroup.bsky.social

Subscribe to the Vanguard News letters.  To make a tax-deductible donation, please visit davisvanguard.org/donate or give directly through ActBlue.  Your support will ensure that the vital work of the Vanguard continues.

Categories:

Breaking News Everyday Injustice

Tags:

Author

  • Tyler Harty-Rollins

    Tyler Harty-Rollins is a second year political science student at the University of California, Davis. He plans to earn his JD after college and become a practicing attorney. Interested in government misconduct, police reform and the challenges that twenty-first century civil liberties faces, he hopes at the Vanguard to made light of everyday injustices committed against the public.

    View all posts