National Report Challenges Traditional Measures of Prosecutorial Success, Emphasizes Public Safety and Accountability

WASHINGTON — On Nov. 19, Fair and Just Prosecution (FJP) published Setting the Standard: Public Safety, Justice, and Accountability in Prosecution, a national report documenting prosecutorial practices and accountability measures aimed at strengthening public safety.

The report drew on interviews with prosecutors leading 26 offices and an extensive review of policies and practices across 29 jurisdictions representing diverse geographic, urban and rural settings.

The report examines approaches to prosecutorial decision-making, crime prevention, gun violence, conviction integrity, victim services and transparency. It highlights how prosecutors’ offices can improve discovery compliance, address law enforcement misconduct, review questionable convictions and use data to strengthen decision-making.

In the report’s introduction, FJP Executive Director Aramis N. Donell challenged traditional measures of prosecutorial effectiveness.

“The standard for success cannot be measured only by conviction rates,” Donell wrote.

Donell emphasized that prosecutorial success must also account for community safety and well-being, constitutional rights and the ethical, fair and transparent exercise of prosecutorial authority.

In Kings County, New York, for example, Project Restore Bed-Stuy, a pilot violence-intervention program, incorporated case management, life skills training, mentoring and trauma-informed healing circles to prevent young men from engaging in gun violence.

According to the report, gun violence declined significantly in the area served by the program, the initiative prevented five retaliatory shootings and none of its 30 participants had subsequently been convicted of an act of gun violence.

Following its reported success, the project secured ongoing city funding to expand into other Brooklyn neighborhoods.

Project Restore Bed-Stuy is among several initiatives highlighted in the report that demonstrate multidisciplinary approaches to advancing public safety.

In King County, Washington, the Regional Domestic Violence Firearm Enforcement Unit has sought to reduce gun violence and improve community safety through interagency collaboration and enforcement of firearm relinquishment laws.

The unit, which includes victim advocates, prosecutors, law enforcement and other professionals, has helped coordinate the recovery of more than 6,000 firearms since its establishment on Jan. 1, 2018.

The report also recognizes that for individuals experiencing behavioral health crises or economic hardship, arrest and prosecution alone are often insufficient to address the underlying causes of instability. Instead, contact with the criminal justice system can exacerbate existing crises.

In Contra Costa County, California, the Neighborhood Restorative Partnership offers eligible adults accused of nonviolent misdemeanors and felonies a community-based alternative to traditional prosecution. According to the report, the program has a recidivism rate of approximately 1%.

“We have to ask if we’re truly meeting crime victims’ needs, and too often the answer is that the traditional approach could be improved,” said Douglas County, Georgia, District Attorney Dalia Racine.

“That’s why we chose to innovate. Through our partnership with the Chamber of Commerce, we can quickly help victims replace a slashed tire, repair a kicked-in door, or board up broken windows. These immediate supports can make a real difference at a moment when people need it most.”

Prosecutors and defense attorneys have also engaged in collaborative efforts to enhance the fairness and effectiveness of the justice system.

Such arrangements allow defense counsel to participate in the development and oversight of diversion programs and sentencing review processes while prosecutors retain responsibility for eligibility determinations and case-related decisions.

In Boulder County, Colorado, the Conviction Integrity Unit assigns plausible claims of innocence to a team consisting of a prosecutor with no prior involvement in the case and an outside defense attorney.

Prosecutors’ offices have also sought to hold corporations accountable for economic exploitation and workplace safety violations.

The Travis County District Attorney’s Office in Texas has partnered with labor unions and federal agencies, including the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, to pursue wage theft and labor violations, resulting in what the report describes as the first corporate conviction for a worker’s death in more than 30 years.

Partnerships with independent researchers have allowed prosecutors’ offices to identify systemic biases, share data and increase transparency through publicly accessible dashboards.

In Lake County, Illinois, the prosecutor’s office launched a public data dashboard to track case filings, outcomes and demographics. An examination of its Alternative Prosecution Program found that it disproportionately benefited white individuals between 2014 and 2020.

By identifying and removing subjective screening barriers, the office reversed that trend, with people of color accounting for 61% of new program participants.

In Washtenaw County, Michigan, the Prosecutor Transparency Project’s partnership with the ACLU of Michigan, the University of Michigan Law School and Poverty Solutions provided independent academic researchers access to nearly 35,000 internal case files.

The resulting research revealed significant racial inequities that existed before cases even reached the prosecutor’s office.

To comment please go to one of these social media platforms:

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DavisVanguard

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoples-vanguard-of-davis-inc/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davisvanguard/

X: https://x.com/davisvanguard

Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/vanguardnewsgroup.bsky.social

Subscribe to the Vanguard News letters.  To make a tax-deductible donation, please visit davisvanguard.org/donate or give directly through ActBlue.  Your support will ensure that the vital work of the Vanguard continues.

Categories:

Breaking News Everyday Injustice

Tags:

Author

  • Eva Jia

    Eva Jia is a rising third-year Criminology and Philosophy double major at the University of California, Irvine. Her academic interests include criminal law and immigration law, and she plans to attend law school after completing her bachelor’s degree. Since her freshman year, Eva has been an active staff member of UCI’s official campus newspaper, where she has developed a strong interest in journalism. Through her internship at the Vanguard, she hopes to bridge her passions for journalism and legal studies, contribute to Vanguard's mission, and create meaningful, tangible change.

    View all posts