DAVIS, Calif. — Following a lengthy and sometimes contentious discussion that stretched well past midnight, the Davis City Council voted unanimously to close the city’s Daytime Respite Center at 530 L St. by Feb. 26, 2027, while directing staff to return in December with detailed plans for replacing services and potentially relocating the center to City Hall.
The 5-0 vote early Wednesday morning followed an extended council debate over whether the city should eliminate one of its principal daytime service locations for unhoused residents without first establishing precisely how those services would be replaced.
Although council members generally agreed that the current location was inadequate and that the city needed to reconsider how it delivers homeless services, they sharply disagreed over whether the city should maintain a dedicated respite center or shift resources toward existing providers, expanded outreach and additional overnight shelter.
The final motion, introduced by Councilmember Josh Chapman and seconded by Vice Mayor Gloria Partida, requires staff to return Dec. 15 with an expenditure plan detailing how resources could be redirected toward expanded services, including those provided by Davis Community Meals and Housing, as well as an assessment of the costs and operational impacts of establishing a respite center at City Hall.
An amendment proposed by Councilmember Bapu Vaitla would require continuity of respite services if the council ultimately chooses to relocate the program, making Feb. 26 the earliest possible closure date under that alternative.
The decision represented a modification of the original recommendation from Mayor Donna Neville and Partida, who serve on the council’s Respite Center Subcommittee.
Their Nov. 8 memorandum and accompanying staff report recommended closing the facility as early as Dec. 15, 2026, and redirecting resources toward other homeless services.
Neville acknowledged that the recommendation had been difficult to develop and that she had hoped the center could remain open through the winter.
“This is not the recommendation we wanted to be sitting here making tonight,” Neville said, explaining that the subcommittee had spent months developing another potential solution that ultimately failed to materialize.
She said the city was confronting limited financial resources, concerns about the current facility and questions about whether its existing approach was effectively serving people experiencing homelessness.
“I certainly did not, in making the recommendation, did not want it to close on December 15, believe me,” Neville said. “I had hoped that it could stay open through the winter months and as we continue to get all the things really firmly in place.”
Partida defended the need to fundamentally reconsider the city’s approach, arguing that existing expenditures were not producing sufficient results.
“We are putting in currently $1.5 million into homeless services, into the support that we are giving to people who are unhoused,” Partida said. “That’s a lot of money. It doesn’t show.”
She argued that maintaining the existing respite center was limiting the city’s ability to develop alternative programs, including more overnight shelter and expanded outreach.
“The money that we are putting out is not making the difference in people’s lives that it should be making,” Partida said. “And I think that we can do better.”
Partida also spoke about her personal experiences with homelessness, describing periods when her family was unable to pay rent and recalling living in a car with her three children.
“I understand this problem and I want to do something about it,” she said.
The financial considerations were central to the subcommittee’s recommendation.
According to the staff report, the respite center operates on an annual budget of approximately $569,000, including $266,000 from the city’s General Fund and $303,000 in grant funding.
The city currently spends approximately $1.55 million annually on the respite center, homeless outreach and authorized shelter beds.
Staff also identified substantial overlap between people using the respite center and those receiving services at Paul’s Place, the resource center operated by Davis Community Meals and Housing.
A comparison of three months of participation records found that 83 of 101 respite center participants, approximately 82%, were also known to and actively using Paul’s Place.
City staff emphasized those findings during the meeting, arguing that the overlap raised questions about whether the city was using its resources efficiently.
Staff said the respite center averages approximately 24 visitors daily, with many also receiving services at Paul’s Place.
However, the overlap became a central point of contention because some council members questioned whether accessing both facilities necessarily meant that the services were duplicative.
Vaitla argued that the city was being asked to eliminate an established program without a sufficiently developed alternative.
“It’s great to say that we’re going to save resources and redirect them, but there’s no plan,” Vaitla said. “What are we going to do? Actually, who are we giving the money to for what? There’s no plan.”
He said the proposal effectively asked council members to close the center and trust that the resources would eventually be redirected toward something beneficial.
“Option one is just an absolute non-starter for me,” he said.
Vaitla was particularly critical of the original December closure date, warning about the consequences of eliminating a daytime refuge during winter.
“The fact that we would consider that is, to me, it’s beyond the optics,” he said, adding that if the city were trying to select the worst possible time to close the center, it would choose a date between mid-December and the end of February.
He also rejected staffing shortages and anticipated parental leave as sufficient reasons to accelerate closure.
“People take parental leave and we plan for it,” Vaitla said. “That cannot be an issue. We need to just manage these resource shortages.”
Vaitla argued that the city should commit to relocating the center while maintaining uninterrupted services.
“We also know that the respite center model works in other places,” he said. “What is happening is that we haven’t made it work at this particular location in the way that we’ve done it, with the infrastructure that we have, et cetera.”
He suggested that the city explore modular facilities and other infrastructure options rather than abandoning the respite model.
“There isn’t a single day where we don’t have the respite center running,” Vaitla said.
A central disagreement involved whether Paul’s Place could adequately serve everyone currently using the city-operated facility.
Vaitla praised Davis Community Meals and Housing but said he had repeatedly heard from unhoused residents who did not feel comfortable accessing its services.
“I want two touch points in town,” Vaitla said. “I don’t think it’s prudent given the information that we have to invest all of our resources in a single nonprofit.”
A representative of Davis Community Meals and Housing responded that the organization welcomes people seeking assistance but maintains behavioral expectations intended to ensure safety.
The representative acknowledged that some people may not be comfortable with the organization and said it should not be the only option available.
“I don’t think we should be the only option,” the representative said. “We are not the end all be all for everybody.”
The representative reported that Paul’s Place completed intakes for 831 unique individuals during the fiscal year ending June 30, including 584 who identified as unsheltered.
The resource center now serves approximately 180 people daily, compared with an estimated 40 to 50 daily visitors in 2019, according to the representative.
Partida argued that outreach workers could provide additional points of contact without requiring the city to maintain another physical facility.
“Does there have to be a location for there to be another touch point?” she asked.
Vaitla responded by questioning where people would go if they needed a place to get out of the weather.
Neville acknowledged that many individuals use both Paul’s Place and the respite center for different purposes.
She described people who visit Paul’s Place for breakfast or showers before going to the respite center because it offers more space and a less crowded environment.
“They’re just looking for a place where no one’s going to bother them where they’re out of the elements,” Neville said. “We have to be able to find some other place people can do that.”
She suggested that churches and other community facilities might provide alternative daytime warming spaces.
The exchange highlighted a fundamental disagreement over whether the primary purpose of the respite center should be connecting people with services or providing a physical refuge from the elements.
Partida maintained that the city could achieve better results by strengthening its outreach operations and directing resources toward services that help people move out of homelessness.
She also raised the possibility of increasing overnight shelter capacity through the city’s existing hotel program.
The city currently has access to eight shelter beds at Paul’s Place and five at Fourth and Hope, along with hotel rooms at High Wheel Flats reserved primarily for medically vulnerable individuals and seniors.
Staff said the number of hotel rooms was still being negotiated, although the city had previously secured as many as 10 rooms and had expanded capacity under special circumstances.
Partida suggested that increasing the number of hotel rooms could provide more meaningful assistance than continuing to devote substantial resources to the existing daytime facility.
“If there is a way that we could double the beds that we have through the hotel system, that would be better for folks,” she said.
Staff cautioned that expanding hotel shelter would also require additional personnel to provide case management and daily support.
Neville noted that the council had recently authorized up to an additional $50,000 for overnight shelter.
The discussion eventually shifted toward finding a compromise that would allow the city to leave the L Street property without immediately committing to a single replacement model.
Chapman said he supported moving away from the existing location but wanted a detailed understanding of what would happen to the people currently using the facility.
He suggested that the city establish a closure date near the end of February and use the intervening months to develop specific alternatives.
Those alternatives would include reallocating funds toward expanded services at Paul’s Place or establishing a modified respite operation at the city-owned modular building at City Hall.
Chapman repeatedly questioned whether the council had sufficient information about either approach.
“Where are those dollars? What’s the plan for this?” he asked.
He said the city needed to establish expectations, costs and accountability before making decisions about redirecting funding.
“Where is the accountability for where those dollars are going?” Chapman said.
Neville clarified that closing the respite center would not necessarily mean transferring its entire budget to Davis Community Meals and Housing.
She said potential uses included expanded overnight hotel shelter, additional outreach and other services that the council would ultimately determine.
“It could be us funding more overnight hotel rooms,” Neville said. “It could be any number of things we choose to do.”
The discussion also addressed the possibility of relocating services to the city-owned modular building at City Hall.
The staff report estimated approximately $100,000 in relocation and modification expenses for that option, but staff explained that the building lacks the space and infrastructure to replicate all services currently available at L Street.
In particular, the modular facility could accommodate navigation and outreach functions but could not provide showers or laundry facilities.
Staff also said restroom access would likely depend on existing City Hall facilities.
Chapman said those limitations needed to be documented before the council could make an informed decision.
“I just don’t feel that the information that’s there is appropriate to make that decision,” he said.
The city had previously considered relocating the respite center to city-owned duplexes near Paul’s Place, but those properties are currently occupied by families participating in transitional housing programs.
Council members expressed reluctance to displace those families to accommodate the relocation.
The subcommittee had also explored an arrangement involving the Yolo County Health and Human Services Agency building at 600 A St., but that effort did not produce an agreement.
As the discussion continued into the early morning, Councilmember Linda Deos initially moved to adopt the subcommittee recommendation with a later closure date of March 1.
Neville seconded that motion, which was amended to require staff to return with recommendations for allocating the savings.
Vaitla subsequently proposed relocating respite operations to City Hall while maintaining continuity of services, but that substitute motion did not receive a second.
Chapman then offered the substitute motion that ultimately prevailed, setting Feb. 26 as the L Street closure deadline and requiring detailed alternatives to return to council Dec. 15.
Partida seconded the motion.
Vaitla proposed an amendment ensuring that if the council chooses to continue respite services at another location, the existing center would remain open until replacement services could begin.
Chapman accepted the amendment.
Neville added a further requirement that staff examine how using the City Hall modular building would affect the newly named Davis Community Services Community Response Team.
The council approved the amended substitute motion unanimously.
The decision establishes a deadline for ending operations at the current L Street location while leaving the future of the respite program itself unresolved.
Staff must now develop specific proposals for reallocating resources, expanding services through existing providers and potentially maintaining a modified respite center at City Hall.
The council is scheduled to revisit those options Dec. 15, when members will consider the costs, operational requirements and implications for people currently relying on the L Street facility.
To comment please go to one of these social media platforms:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DavisVanguard
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoples-vanguard-of-davis-inc/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davisvanguard/
X: https://x.com/davisvanguard
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/vanguardnewsgroup.bsky.social
Subscribe to the Vanguard News letters. To make a tax-deductible donation, please visit davisvanguard.org/donate or give directly through ActBlue. Your support will ensure that the vital work of the Vanguard continues.